Career change – artistic or egotistical?

by Rory Macdowall
It is almost a cliché that an actor who reaches a certain level of recognition declares that he, or she, would eventually like to try their hand at directing. With recent releases Argo and Corolianus notable for their A-list directors, Ben Affleck and Ralph Fiennes respectively, the question surrounding actors’ adaptability to directing has resurfaced. But how many of those who venture to the other side of the camera find success?
Most would agree that Ben Affleck’s acting performances have been a mixed bag: despite strong work in Good Will Hunting and Hollywoodland, the majority of his on-screen outings have left something to be desired. Daredevil was the most forgettable superhero film of the current craze.
However, Affleck’s work behind the camera has garnered a huge amount of attention, particularly his recent release Argo. Affleck announced himself as a screenwriter in 1997 following years of fruitless background acting work. His work in Good Will Hunting, for which he shared acting and writing credits with friend Matt Damon, earned him an Oscar for best screenplay. Through his more recent work in Gone Baby Gone and The Town, Ben Affleck has proven his natural knack for capturing drama and grit on camera, and he is one of very few actors to have cultivated a fanbase as a director. Affleck has hinted that Argo may be among the last films in which he acts and directs: “The focus that you have to put in as an actor just takes away from the bandwidth of your concentration (as a director)”.
In some ways the opposite of Ben Affleck, who became simultaneously prominent as an actor and a writer, is Clint Eastwood. Eastwood had long been known as ‘the man with no name’, a tough, silent character from Sergio Leone’s legendary westerns, but shed this image as he began to direct emotionally challenging films. Clint Eastwood has since been prolific in his output of good work, and still surprises audiences and critics with his ability to tackle genre after genre.
Affleck and Eastwood share a love for their medium and, most importantly, an ability to learn. Affleck talks passionately in interviews about what he gains artistically from working with legendary directors such as Terrence Malick and Gus Van Sant. Having the opportunity to spend weeks or months on end with such talented artists is clearly beneficial, but being a well-known actor certainly does not give one a ‘free pass’ to become a top Hollywood director. From the perspective of the studios, the involvement of a famous actor in production does not necessarily sell tickets. Ralph Fiennes’ directorial debut Coriolanus was received positively by critics but performed slowly at the box office, and George Clooney’s Leatherheads netted Universal Studios a loss. Any success that actors have in directing is merited.
In some cases, actors’ careers in front of the camera have been almost forgotten in favour of their more illustrious directorial achievements. The likes of Orson Welles and Charlie Chaplin are quite rightly recognised for their tremendous contributions to filmmaking in the first half of the 20th century, but both started out in show business as actors. More recently, Mel Gibson and Kevin Costner each enjoyed spells as award-winning directors who commanded very high budgets. Costner’s Dances With Wolves and Gibson’s Braveheart were both Oscar winners in the 90s, somehow beating Goodfellas and Heat respectively. However, Kevin Costner’s directing career took a turn for the worse as he troubled studios with a string of bombs; The Postman was one of the worst box office disasters in cinema history.
Many actors’ recent directorial ventures have performed particularly well in awards season. Paddy Considine’s Tyrannosaur earned him a BAFTA for best new director, and Clooney’s The Ides of March was nominated for an Oscar. With the ever-fascinating Andy Serkis assisting Peter Jackson as second unit director for The Hobbit, it appears that the landscape for aspiring actor-directors is far from bleak.
Argo is in cinemas now
