TV shoot-out in Durham cathedral: a step too far?
The BBC drama ‘Inspector George Gently’ last week concluded with a fatal shoot-out filmed on location in Durham Cathedral. With bullets clearly seen to damage religious artefacts and innocent choirboys witnessing attempted murder, the episode has become contentious. The sight of bullets ricocheting around a UNESCO World Heritage Site caused unease. Not only is the cathedral a protected building, but one of extreme religious significance.
As a Theology student, the arising controversy has interested me greatly: was this a justifiably dramatic moment or a shameful desecration?
The BBC based the episode on T. S. Eliot’s 1935 play ‘Murder in the Cathedral’, which dramatises Archbishop Thomas Becket’s assassination in Canterbury Cathedral. Likewise in Shakespeare’s ‘Romeo and Juliet’, the famous “star-cross’d lovers” both commit the cardinal sin of suicide in the Capulet Crypt of the church. Clearly, history is no stranger to this debate.
Evidently religious buildings have been used to depict violence throughout the centuries, but is this decision an acceptable one?
Those who responded angrily to the BBC episode questioned the usage of weaponry in a place supposed to represent peace and protection. On the surface, they have a point. Christianity is an inherently non-violent religion, with Jesus promoting his golden rule to “love thy neighbour” and Matthew 5:9 proclaiming “blessed are the peacemakers”.
However, although it is an important emblem of faith, I do not believe the character of the cathedral has been ‘violated’ by the decision to stage a shootout within its walls. In contrast, the BBC producers were evidently keen to draw upon religious themes.
The storyline was one of morality. Corrupt police officers responsible for fraud and murder covertly worked alongside criminals to try and frame Inspector Gently, himself entirely sincere. Eventually good triumphed over evil in the cathedral showdown, restoring justice and integrity within the Force.
The idea of remorse also featured; Gently apologised for failing to trust his Sergeant and for leaving him unarmed, a move that left the latter with potentially fatal injuries, drawing parallels with John 15:13, “no one has greater love than this, that he lay his life down for his friends”.
So while the episode was violent, this violence helped promote the cathedral and its message to the public. A cathedral spokesman emphasized this, explaining that “bad things sometimes happen in sacred places” and that worship may not be the only occurance in a religious setting.
Given the increasing secularization of Britain, religious buildings cannot be solely marketed to those with faith. The cathedral relies heavily on donations for its upkeep, and without publicity this will not be achieved. Featuring it during a primetime television slot on a major channel such as the BBC will undoubtedly be positive for tourism, an advantage the cathedral cannot afford to refuse.
Many Facebook fans of the building recognized this, praising the producers for their style of filming. The camera panned in on the cathedral’s intricate architecture and stain glass windows, showcasing the very best to over 4.3 million viewers. The Facebook page likewise urges fans to contribute to its upkeep, pointing out that it is the only large medieval cathedral in Britain which does not charge for entry.
Consequently, we cannot be too scared to use religious buildings for dramatic purposes through fear of offending a minority. If religious trepidation amongst society prevents the media from having access to buildings such as the cathedral it is we, the public, who ultimately lose out.
This three part series was filmed exclusively in the North East, including in St Mary’s College and on Palace Green, and I believe there really was no better place for the finale than a location at the very heart of the city.
The BBC’s filming did not violate the cathedral, nor should it have offended religious believers.
Instead it celebrated the magnificent beauty of ‘Britain’s Best Building’, as voted in a Guardian survey last year, and proudly showcased it for all to see.
Photograph: Lucy Edwardes Jones
Illustration: Sean Mui

