Disqualified candidate has “full respect” for JCR decision
by Sally Wardle
A candidate disqualified from the Trevelyan College presidential election has spoken of his respect for the JCR.
Earlier this week, Trevelyan President, Nick Cooper, defended the JCR’s decision to disqualify Jeremiah Riad after he broke rules regarding election publicity.
Trevelyan College standing orders state, “No materials may be given out to voters during canvassing.”
The election guidelines also state that “a candidate may not utilise poster campaigns nor any form of electronic media at any point in their campaign. Candidates may publicise the method of voting in an impartial manner as deemed appropriate by the JCR Chair.”
In an open letter to the students, JCR Chair Benjamin Lambert explained the reasoning behind the steering committee’s decision to disqualify Jeremiah:
“On Friday the 25th of January a website, www.votejerry.org, and a Facebook page of the name ‘Vote Jerry’ were brought to my attention by members of the JCR.”
He continues, “Despite meeting with the candidate that evening and raising concerns, Mr. Riad ‘liked’ both the page itself and multiple comments on the page, implicitly endorsing it.
“He did so without publicly disowning the page, or being in further contact with myself.”
The JCR chair summarised, “the fact that Mr. Riad has not disowned the page publicly, and made no known attempt to get the page removed, suggests that he is utilising electronic media, even if he is not directly responsible for it.”
A Facebook user ‘Suzie Sandwiches’ has claimed responsibility for the creation of the page and electronic media in relation to the campaign. However a student by this name is not registered at the University.
Despite claims otherwise, JCR President Nick Cooper asserted that “no formal appeal by the candidate in question has ever been made.
“In reality, the entire situation boils down to complaints made by others on behalf of the candidate, which have been dealt with promptly and precisely, in accordance with the JCR Complaints Procedure.”
On Wednesday, Nick Cooper voiced his support for the actions of the JCR Chair and Steering Committee, who “acted in full accordance with the governing documents of the JCR and have the support of both the Executive Committee and the College Officers in this matter.”
Speaking to Palatinate, Jeremiah Riad stated “I am more disappointed than angry over my disqualification from the JCR elections.
“Countless hours of effort and hard work were put in by both myself and my team in preparing this campaign, and to not even get the chance to see it through to the end was hugely demoralising.”
However, he added “the JCR had, and still have, my full respect, and I believe that they do their best to act within the interests of members of the college.”
In light of the controversy, Benjamin Lambert has responded to claims that Trevelyan Standing Orders relating to electronic publicity are outdated:
“The rules on social networking were considered and maintained as they are at last year’s constitutional review, which is open to any member of the JCR to attend.
“People are free to propose a change to the rules at any JCR meeting, one of which was held at the start of this term.
“If Mr. Riad, or anyone else, wanted to update this section, that is the correct channel, and I look forward as ever to our upcoming JCR meeting this Sunday.”
One second year at Trevelyan College, who did not wish to be named, commented, “I think this is awful and the complete opposite of what the exec should be concentrating on at the moment- trying to get more people involved in the running of the JCR.”
Jeremiah Riad added to this debate: “If the standing orders are changed as a result of this controversy […] then some good may have come from this campaign.”
Following the disqualification, just one candidate Adam Thompson, is in the running for the role of President.
The results of the election will be announced In Trevelyan College bar at 7.30pm on Friday.
The creator of the ‘Vote Jerry’ Facebook page did not respond to a request for comment.

