Too soon for Covid TV?
By Jessica Donaldson
I will be the first to admit that I would watch Jodie Comer in anything. Killing Eve is one of my all-time favourite TV shows. I have no interest in video games but paid to see Free Guy in cinemas. She’s hugely talented, funny and remarkably relatable. Yet, sitting with my parents on a Friday night watching Channel 4’s Help, my mum asked why we had chosen to watch this show. Namely, because it wasn’t the most cheerful choice for a Friday evening, but she also questioned how much she liked the idea of watching something revolving around the pandemic. The thought had crossed all of our minds — was it too soon to be watching a show about Covid-19?
The portrayal of Covid-19 is grounded, real, and honest.
Don’t get me wrong — Help is brilliant. The show features Comer as Sarah, a carer working in a Liverpool care home, and fellow Liverpudlian Stephen Graham as a resident with early-onset Alzheimer’s. It explores the harsh realities of the early days of the pandemic and the difficulties care homes faced. The home struggles to access PPE and, as a result, a number of the vulnerable residents are infected with coronavirus and several sadly pass away. Perhaps the most striking part of the episode comes about halfway through — a 26 minute, single-take scene following Sarah as she struggles alone on the night shift. Kenny, one of the older residents, becomes seriously unwell with Covid-19. Despite Sarah’s frantic phone calls, no ambulance or doctor responds. As Sarah stays on the line, the continuous NHS 111 answer machine is incredibly poignant — their care home has been forgotten. At the end of the episode, the fourth wall is broken as Sarah makes an emotional appeal to the audience — she criticises the government’s lack of care for care homes, those in poverty and others struggling during the pandemic. She says that our country cannot carry on like this. The scene is followed by statistics about mistakes made and the lives lost. The portrayal of Covid-19 is grounded, real and honest. But should shows feature coronavirus with the shadow of the pandemic still lingering over us?
The pandemic is primarily a plot device, a feature to attract viewers who wanted to see departed characters return.
Across the pond, the American TV show Grey’s Anatomy also tackled the issue of Covid-19. Having not seen the new season myself yet, my friend described their handling of the pandemic as “how they handle all issues on the show” — with drama, suspense and overarching episode arcs. Meredith, the main character in the show, catches coronavirus herself and falls into a coma. However, Meredith’s journey with Covid-19 drastically differs from Sarah’s. Instead of spending time on the phone to NHS 111, each episode in her coma lets her reunite with a departed character from days of Grey’s past. Patrick Dempsey shows up on an idyllic beach for a reunion. She gets to see her half-sister again. The portrayal of Covid here is less gritty realism, and more fan wish fulfilment. The pandemic is primarily a plot device, featured to attract viewers who wanted to see departed characters return. Despite its reasonably accurate portrayal of a hospital during Covid, it is overshadowed by the weekly anticipation and guesswork about which character Meredith would see on the beach next.
So is it too soon for pandemic dramas? Well, yes and no. I think Help gets it largely right. Comer’s portrayal is magnificent and genuinely captures the helplessness of care homes at the start of the pandemic. Rather than a drama, Help feels more like a documentary. Much like Comer’s character in Help, care home workers were forced to wear bin bags instead of PPE in Spring 2020. Over about a year, almost 40,000 care home residents had died due to Covid-19. Residents and staff alike were forgotten. Help captures this entirely, exploring the issue with tact and realism. By the end, I felt even angrier at the governmental handling of the pandemic than I had before.
But a critique of the government’s handling of the pandemic and abandonment of care workers and the elderly? I’d say it’s well overdue.
I was, however, lucky enough to have been largely unaffected by Covid-19 — my family has been healthy throughout, and my friends have gotten over the festival-induced bouts quickly. I can’t imagine how it would feel watching such shows having lost someone to the disease. We need a balance between utilising the pandemic as entertainment and affording it the sensitivity it deserves. Grey’s Anatomy fulfils the entertainment part but with less tact. Help, by comparison, achieves this balance — it makes for tense and exciting viewing, without exploiting the issues for dramatic effect. It is too soon for a version of Covid-19 featured only as a plot device. But a critique of the government’s handling of the pandemic and abandonment of care workers and the elderly? I’d say it is well overdue.
Image Credits: Mulyadi via Unsplash

