Euphoria’s complex characters: dismissed too quickly?
By Jessica Donaldson
With every episode of Euphoria’s second season this year, discourse flowed on TikTok and other social media platforms surrounding the events of that week’s 50 minutes of drama and disputes. Whether it was fan theories or character edits, there was no escaping the endless commentary on each successive episode. There were also huge amounts of criticism and analysis, perhaps considerably more so than the first season. Largely, the greatest criticism revolved around the portrayal of some of the show’s characters in comparison to the preceding season.
Cassie and Jules, two of Euphoria’s main characters, make questionable decisions throughout Season 2 that sharply contrast their Season 1 character development. Kat, portrayed by Barbie Ferreira, attracted similar discussions and, according to most, was vastly underused and underdeveloped this season. The tone of the portrayal of these three characters sharply contrasted their Season 1 character arcs — by the end of season one, Cassie, for example, seemed to have reached an element of contentedness following her struggles with her boyfriend throughout the rest of the season. By contrast, even from the first episode of the following season, Cassie is considerably more volatile and unstable than her character development would have suggested. Why such change occurs is never really explained. Kat, having found herself in a happy and contended relationship by the end of the first season, fakes a brain tumour to break-up with her boyfriend. The consequences of this are never touched on again. Similarly, Jules, portrayed by Hunter Schafer, in Season 1’s exploration of her character’s transitioning process, explains that she has hyperfeminised herself as a result of the male gaze and largely prefers women to men. In Season 2, however, she is largely defined by her interactions with new male character Elliot, with whom she cheats on her girlfriend and lead character, Rue.
When we encounter a character that exists outside of our expectations… we sideline or criticise them
What is common to all three characters is the undeniable layers to their personality and decisions. Yet, despite such layers, in Season 2, Sam Levinson largely reduces them to one dimensional portrayals. I think many of the flaws with both Cassie and Jules rest in the frequency with which we dismiss complex characters. Digital Spy published an article explaining how Euphoria Season 2 had “failed” Jules’ character, criticising her side-lining throughout the episodes. Vogue highlighted the “downgrading” of Kat, and Sydney Sweeney, the actress who portrays Cassie in the show, said that she was “completely thrown off” by the depiction of her character this season. Levinson, though setting these characters up as layered, complex and multidimensional, fails to follow through on their development. Jules and Kat are largely dismissed in Season 2 when they become too complex to portray; Cassie attracted endless criticism on social media for her Season 2 actions, dismissed as a “stupid b*tch” among other less polite accolades.
I think this treatment of these characters is part of a wider problem of our continuous dismissal of, and struggle to portray, difficult characters and more specifically, difficult women. When we encounter a character that exists outside of our expectations as to how they should act or be portrayed — Jules’ identity as a transgender woman is perhaps the clearest example of this — we sideline or criticise them. When her character becomes too complex compared to what the audience might have expected from her portrayal, she is dismissed — both by the writers of the show and the audience. What were once three interesting and multidimensional female characters are therefore reduced or ignored. I think there is a real argument to be made for a re-examination of how we treat complex characters in film and television. We must acknowledge that characters can be one thing, but also simultaneously another. Euphoria’s Kat can be in a steady, healthy relationship whilst also contributing meaningfully to the show. Cassie can be a free-spirited, confident woman whilst also respecting her female friendships. Such complexities go unexamined in Euphoria and, accordingly, both the audience and the show disregard them. We must push for considerably more understanding portrayals and attitudes towards such individuals.
Image Credits: Alexander Popov via Unsplash

