To C or not to C: assessing the difficulties in Hinkley Point C

By Tom Raines

In a blow to the UK government’s strategy of moving towards a more sustainable energy mix, EDF have announced that the opening of Hinkley Point C will be delayed until at least 2029, and likely 2031. Hinkley Point C, the chief new nuclear power station, initially planned to be operational in 2027, and the delay has been coupled with continually rising costs. Rising from £25 billion to at least £35 billion, footing the bill for Hinkley Point C has strained relationships between EDF and the UK government, whilst all of this is ongoing amidst the government’s volte-face over environmental policy.

Hinkley Point C was initially greenlit in June 2016 by the UK government and expected to cost ÂŁ18 billion, with funding split between the government, EDF and China General Nuclear (CGN). Both EDF and CGN were state-owned by France and China respectively, causing their taxpayers to have to fund any increase in funding. The initial plan was for Hinkley Point C to directly replace Hinkley Point B, which closed in 2022, as part of a smoother transition in nuclear power. 

The delay to Hinkley Point C might prove pivotal in the medium-term to UK nuclear power

However, a significant blow was dealt to the project in December 2022 when CGN withdrew its funding for the project, forcing the government to take on the shortage of investment in Hinkley Point C and other nuclear projects where CGN were involved, notably the proposed Sizewell C plant in Suffolk.

The delay to Hinkley Point C might prove pivotal in the medium-term to UK nuclear power. The new generation of nuclear reactors was supposed to seamlessly replace those who have been retired in recent years, including Dungeness B in 2021 as well as Hinkley Point B. This problem is likely to be exacerbated in the coming years with the expected closing of Heysham 1 and Hartlepool nuclear reactors in 2026. Forecasts from the Nuclear Industry Association suggest the nuclear power capacity of the UK is likely to dwindle from 5.88GW in 2023 to just 2.86GW by 2031. To plug this gap, there is a chance existing energy resources become once again more expensive, whilst gas and coal energy sources may be further depleted to take on the shortfall.

Politically, there has been some backlash to the delayed opening and rising costs of Hinkley Point C. French taxpayers have become increasingly opposed to footing the increase in funding for a foreign nuclear reactor, through EDF’s involvement in the project. Meanwhile, Anglo-French cooperation over nuclear power is clearly waning relative to when Hinkley Point C was announced. With issues of inflation and rising debt all straining government budgets, spending on new nuclear reactors is far less desirable for political leaders, especially foreign nuclear reactors in the case of France.

French taxpayers have become increasingly opposed to footing the increase in funding for a foreign nuclear reactor.

The delays to Hinkley Point C add to the mixed picture of a changing energy mix and infrastructure in the UK. There have been many successes in the announcement and initial investment for renewable projects, not least carbon capture and storage facilities. Nuclear power in particular is planned to undergo a boom in the following decades, with the Great British Nuclear organisation forecasting nuclear power will make up 25% of UK energy by 2050. Consumer-side enthusiasm has also been crucial to help move the needle on UK energy policy, seen by the rapid growth of electric vehicles and its charging stations nationwide.

Despite these successes, it is not clear these attempts will be sufficient to achieve net zero by 2050 in the UK. In renewable energy industries, there are simply not enough engineers and electricians to support its expansion, making it more difficult to finance and deliver the expansion of wind and solar farms. The proposed employment boom arising from renewable energy appears not to have materialised in the UK, with industries under-staffed and often outsourcing projects abroad, limiting the political ability to talk up a shift to net zero. These factors have created a slower than expected pace in cutting emissions, with the UK government admitting it is only likely to achieve 92% of its emissions target by 2030.

Hinkley Point C represents a symbol of the non-linearity of UK energy policy and developments in the face of the climate crisis

Simultaneously, the relative U-turn by the Conservatives over net zero means the delays and rising costs of Hinkley Point C might play into their ability to cast net zero as overly ambitious and potentially unfeasible by 2050, although they are still keen to promote the boom of electric vehicles and potential employment opportunities. Electoral successes over Hinkley Point C might equally be found by Labour, given the clear value-for-money issues for taxpayers from the project, given the expected cost is close to double what was expected in 2016.

Hinkley Point C represents a symbol of the non-linearity of UK energy policy and developments in the face of the climate crisis, with its announcement and construction being faced with both time and financial difficulties. Despite being the flagship nuclear project in the UK, political leaders are not overly forthcoming in talking about the project, perhaps a sign of the stymied opportunities of Hinkley Point C relative to 2016, or maybe the potential medium-term difficulties to energy generation.

Image: Robin Somes via Geograph

Tom Raines discusses the announced delay in the opening of a new nuclear reactor, considering domestic and foreign policy implications for the UK.