Three’s valuable company in Never Let Me Go
by Harriet Casey
The biggest misconception I’ve heard about Never Let Me Go is that it’s of the sci-fi inclination. Let me clear that up for you: it’s not. If you’re expecting a fictional universe filled with aliens and physics and action then this is definitely not the film for you. What you will get is a poignant philosophical drama about lives that are cut short. The setting is technically an alternate reality and there are some science-fiction elements: it’s the story of a dystopian England that has found cures for degenerative diseases. However, these cures require “donors” who are human clones created to donate themselves to science when they are fully matured adults. There are no further explanations about the cures; this is as scientific as it gets.
The story follows three of these donors through their misleadingly idyllic childhood at Hailsham, a boarding school in a typical Hollywood-English countryside mansion. It looks and feels like Atonement’s calmer sibling in many respects: dialogue and dramatic encounters are minimal and you are left to interpret much of the material yourself. This is true to the tone of the book; almost all of the events are in the “past”, narrated from the memories of Kathy (Carey Mulligan), the “present” only surfacing at the story’s end when the plot has come full circle. The book’s author Kazuo Ishiguro worked closely with Alex Garland (of The Beach fame) to create the screenplay and although in some respects the novel and the film are different – the film is more evocative with a quietly moving soundtrack and eerie cinematography – it is a faithful representation of the enclosed world Ishiguro has created.
Mulligan (An Education) is joined by Keira Knightley and Andrew Garfield (The Social Network’s Eduardo Saverin; recently cast as Peter Parker in the Spiderman reboot) as Ruth and Tommy respectively. However, before the three adults appear, the character’s childhoods are played out. I’ve never been a fan of child-to-adult transitions on screen but it works surprisingly well here, partly due to the uncanny resemblance the children have to their older counterparts.
Carey Mulligan’s Kathy is wise beyond her years – passive and calm. She matches well with Garfield’s wide-eyed, easy-going Tommy and contrasts with Knightley’s bitter and irritable Ruth. Ruth is often a venomous antagonist who adds immeasurably to the complexity of the trio’s relationship. Yet despite their blatant differences the three stick together through much of their shared screen time, making for what is often frustrating viewing. This passivity is the hardest aspect of the film to grasp – with the exception of Ruth they are pityingly accepting of their fates.
Whilst the lack of action will surely make this a disappointing experience for many (somebody on my Facebook feed declared it the “WORST FILM EVER”), this is also what makes it such a compelling and haunting film. It is ultimately a study of human nature, of life and love against a troubling background that is always tantalisingly out of reach both for the characters and the audience. It is not a film of triumph, but of acceptance, which is perhaps a reality more tangible and relatable to our own lives than your average overblown thriller.

