Should JCRs give up their independent charitable status?

Tom Filipinski says Yes:

So we’re now into the fifth year after the 2006 Education Act stated that student unions were no longer entitled to their previous status as exempt charities and would in future have to register with the charities commission or find an alternative governance structure. This has finally come to a head because of a registration deadline set by the overstretched Charities Commission of July 2011.

JCRs find themselves in a legally bizarre position as a result of this. Currently, every JCR will have an Executive Committee of some kind, mandated to carry out the “day to day activities” of the organisation, which is a word-for-word definition by the Charities Commission of a “trustee”. Now you would imagine that this is how you would want things to be- Exec as trustees, simples. But currently as trustees, the Exec have unlimited liability. If anything goes wrong, such as if someone is paralysed on a summer ball ent, the trustees can be personally sued/prosecuted if they are found to have been grossly negligent.

So a JCR is currently an unregistered students’ union, with trustees (i.e. the Exec) with unlimited liability, but without the turnover, trading activity or operational infrastructure to be able to viably set up a charitable company limited by guarantee (in the way the DSU has) to remove some of the burden of liability from trustees. Basically it’s a legal nightmare.

JCRs have until this year, only considered the option of registration, but this year a new option of incorporation into the University’s structure has been brought together by the Governance Working Group as a realistic alternative.

So let’s start by looking at the issue of liability in more detail. The only charity registration option currently available is as an Unincorporated Organisation. This is similar to current situation. The trustees will still the face unlimited liability that Execs face currently.

I can hear Adam’s counter, “but you can buy insurance to mitigate against that liability”. Well, that’s true. However, this is a relatively untested area of law, so it is hard to know to what extent that insurance would stand up, and it certainly wouldn’t stand up if the trustees were found to have been negligent. The trustees themselves don’t even need to have been involved in the incident; they are responsible for that charity, so any accidents relating to it are theirs to bear.

On the other hand, the Durham Student Organization (DSO) framework will see the University take on the liability on behalf of JCR officers offering them substantial legal protection. This leaves the officers to focus on the things they are good at. The Social Chairs shall go to the ball; the Presidents can focus on working with people instead of paper. To get this cover, we will need to adhere to the University’s Health and Safety Policy, but we need to do that already, and as a charity we would have to come up with our own health and safety policy as well as the University’s own.

From an employment perspective, as a charity, if a JCR wishes to employ anyone (like a sabbatical president), the trustees of the JCR itself will be responsible for ensuring that the JCR conforms to all relevant employment law. If they want to use the University’s services, including payroll, they will be charged. As a DSO, this will all be taken care of by the University, and while employees will nominally be line-managed, the University has said it will uphold the primacy of a President’s accountability to their constituents.

“So what about managing our finances?” I hear you cry, “Surely the charity option will give us greater financial autonomy?” Well, my misconstruing friend, that is where you’re wrong. As a charity, any expenditure must be justifiable against the charitable aims of the organisation.

There are no such limits on a DSO. While the University will nominally own our assets, we will have free access to spend them as we please. The DSO offers us the closest thing to the financial freedom we currently enjoy.

Another substantial point is that through savings in trustee and contents insurance, and on accountants fees the DSO represents a saving of £6,000-£12,000 depending on the size of the JCR, which is 5-10% of annual turnover for an individual JCR and is worth taking into account.

The final issue in all of this is trust. As a DSO, JCRs will have to take a leap of faith, hoping that the University will stick to the agreement outlined in the framework. Once integrated, the University Council, as the most powerful University body, has the right to tear up the agreement and rewrite it as it sees fit, and JCRs must have some fair idea that this won’t happen. However, this is actually the same in the charitable route. The University has said it won’t charge charity JCRs for the use of space in college but they can just as easily go back on this. From my point of view, in this situation of trust, it is better to be on the inside.

So I have outlined why I would like to adopt the DSO framework, but ultimately the choice is yours to do what is right for your JCR, and secure its future for years to come.

Adam Ruddock says No:

A JCR as a registered charity, running itself, seems like a strangely serious step to take. It begs the simple question; why bother? The answer is simple; JCRs are the root reason that Durham is such a unique place, and this need to be preserved.

The term ‘the Durham difference’ is bandied about a lot, but very rarely is this term actually explained. At Durham, students are, as the cliché goes, offered so many chances to ‘get involved’ in the JCR. These chances range from leading a sports team and organising kit orders and tours, to becoming a welfare officer and looking after hundreds of people. I recently organised a ball, something I’ve never done before in my life. It was terrifying to be in charge of fulfilling so many people’s expectations, not to mention thousands of pounds worth of their money. But I came out of it having withstood the pressure and having organised a successful event. These are the chances for personal development that the JCR alone can offer in such abundance and variety, which makes Durham so special, and contributes more than a simple line on our CVs stating a degree class. That, I submit, is the Durham difference.

Would this difference be damaged by incorporation with the University? With the slide away from college autonomy to centralised control, it is more than a possibility; it’s a likelihood. From the University’s takeover of JCR bars and attempts to standardise formals and catering, through to the ‘Experience Durham’ strategy, local college freedom is slowly being eroded.

An example of this very problem occurred right at the beginning of this year. Before Freshers Week began, a set of guidelines was sent around the colleges including the requirement that Freshers’ Helpers should not organise group trips into town as part of the night-time entertainment, ‘group’ being defined as more than 10 people. Evening activities should instead be restricted to entertainment in college and the bar.

Imagine it. A new year of freshers going to go out into Durham, many of them as part of their first experience with alcohol, unsupervised and unsure even of the layout of the city. This would pose a significant welfare risk, as well as disrupting a tradition designed to instil college spirit. On these grounds the vast majority of the college Helper teams ignored the guidelines. We could do so because we are independent. Take away the independence, and you lose the ability to politely decline. Some may see the decision to go independent as a petulant display of student rebellion. I disagree. An independent JCR does not stick the proverbial middle finger up to the university; nor is it designed to instigate an ‘us and them’ mentality. We are a university, a collective. As such we must all work together to continue the great life we have here at this prestigious establishment, charity or not.

There is the impression that becoming a charity is a lot of work, prohibitively so. While it would be wrong to say it would be easy to register, the barriers in place of registration are not as high as they would seem. The way JCRs do things does not need to change drastically as a result of independence. What is required is to install efficient practices, which can be followed by future generations. The main one of these would be regarding finances. As a registered charity, we would need to have accurate, solid financial structures and accounts to monitor spending. Grey JCR for example, is fortunate to have this in place. Obviously this standard must be maintained, but an accountant would help ensure that financial records will always be of a necessary quality.

An employment scheme would need to be installed to adhere to employment law, but Grey JCR currently only employs one person, a President, lessening the impact of any changes.

A trustee board would be needed, which would control the running of the JCR. This requires a mix of committed students and alumni who have knowledge of a business world required to help a charity run. Grey is lucky to have a strong alumni base, which is willing to help and provide the necessary support.

Finally there is charity law, an animal which has not yet been fully explored and likely won’t be until we are there. The Charity Commission is designed to support and monitor charities, not ruthlessly punish them, and it is with their help that we would run in the future. Grey JCR is by no means special in these regards and all these things are well within the reach of any Durham JCR.

To round off, the important thing to remember is that JCRs are charities right now; a lot of the things we are required to do, we do already. What is needed is a tightening up of those practices. There are thousands of charities in England and Wales, a great number which are smaller than a JCR. There are also other students’ unions which are charities, such as some Oxbridge JCRs. The task is by no means impossible.

Ultimately this decision about the future of the JCRs is not to be taken lightly. The result could alter the life of a Durham student as we know it. But it is a chance. A chance to try new things and make life better for the future. Is that not what our education teaches us? Those JCRs who incorporate with the University will have missed this chance. Even though an opt-out exists, by the time it is possible, three years will have passed. The collective memory of the Durham student body will have been renewed and very few, if any, of those who remember life as it is now, will remain. How do you re-attain something you didn’t even know existed? In addition, the determination of will required to remove a JCR from the University, after a number of years’ worth of reliance upon someone else to do the day-to-day jobs, would be huge. So now is the chance to test the waters. Even if it all fails and a JCR must return cap-in-hand, I for one would prefer to have tried and failed than to spend years wondering ‘what if?’