This week’s PalatiComment mailbag

We at Comment like nothing more than a strong student reaction to our articles. These pieces are on a range of topics which affect you, from national and international politics, to Durham student life, and everything in between. They are written by people with compelling opinions and are intended to inspire conversation and debate. It is inevitable that you will not always agree with what you read, but whatever your reaction, we want to hear from you! Our mailing list features hundreds of people who disagree with the apathetic reputation of Durham students, so when you have something to say about a certain piece comment online, tweet @PalatiComment or email comment@palatinate.org.uk. We’d love to hear your opinion.

This week our articles have had a particularly strong response, and we have picked some of the most interesting reactions to examine…

An article by Nick Bradley argues that religion has no place in state-funded schools, and asks whether it is ‘acceptable for tax-payers money to be spent on preaching the state religion of Saudi Arabia and Iran in British schools?’

Unsurprisingly, this article received a strong reaction. The comment section below the article was full of contributors debating the merits of faith schools and Nick’s forceful stance.

The initial reaction was in opposition to the author of the piece. ‘Sarah’ asked ‘Is this a Daily Mail parody?’ adding, ‘Seriously – this is the worst Palatinate article I have ever read.’

Jack Kellem echoed her views, stating: ‘I thought Peter Hitchens had done a guest article for a minute….’

However, within an hour or so, other commenters wrote defending the piece, ‘ncfb’ calling ‘Sarah’s comment ‘uninformed and juvenile’, and ‘Maryblack’ suggesting to Jack ‘This is a humanist article so pretty sure you have the wrong Hitchens brother…’

Others were equally in support of the article. Joe McArdle commented:

An eloquent and important article; one that articulates the dangers prevalent in a society in which people are ready to support bad ideas out of politeness.

Faith schools are a very real and very serious threat to the scientific literacy of the children in this country, as well as being just one of the problems that are perpetuated by New Labour’s School Standards and Framework Act (1998). This is the legislative abomination intent on transforming schools from educational institutions into business capital.The problem is not that the writings of the Qur’an or the Bible or the Torah are being taught in schools, it is that they are being taught in Science lessons; the problem is that they are being taught as truth, or at least scientifically viable hypotheses.
Until this is wiped out and until religion has become a definitively private practice and not state-funded propaganda, it shall remain as Nietzsche defined it, “the one great innermost corruption… the immortal blemish of humanity”

And ‘SHS’ agreed:

Women here in the UK commenting on this should count themselves lucky that they are educated enough to read it, understand it and then post their thoughts. They have been allowed an education, unlike their Iranian or Saudi Arabian counterparts who would be physically punished for doing the same. Religion being tied to state education is a huge step backwards. What chance does a child stand if it is taught outdated, illogical principals that are based on make believe and fantasy? An then told that if they don’t following them they will burn in hell for eternity. Think of the damage that must do to a young child. It’s disgusting. Too many people see articles that portray religion in a negative light, Islam in particular, and immediately assume that it’s right wing lunacy. Look at the bigger picture and what the author is actually saying and stop being so sensitive.

However, the debate did not become one-sided, ‘Mirza Ahmed’ commenting four times with suggestions for further reading on Islamic blogs discussing religion and science:

Simple question, as this article thinks the Qur’an is against science. What do you think of all the religious Muslim scholars who were also scientists, and contributed much to civilisation and science, such as Ibn Sina (Avicenna)? Reading any of his works, you’ll see him commend the Qur’an and God for inspiring him in his science…

How about, we organise a debate around the place of religion in society, instead of making strawmen (as the article has done)?
You are invited to debate Hamza Tzortsis, please contact http://www.hamzatzortzis.com/ to arrange a debate.
Many times Hamza has argued to debate the humanists, but the humanists have backed down, as they know their arguments cannot withstand critical and logical scrutiny. 

This article was also tweeted by ‘@ones_to_watch’, who promote the best of student media. If you would like to write a reaction piece to Nick please get in touch via comment@palatinate.org.uk.

We also received an article from a Durham student, who wished to remain anonymous, urging her peers not to make light of sexual abuse and to think before they speak.

This piece received a universally positive response online gathering over 100 ‘likes’ within 36 hours. The commenters reacted equally positively, thanking the contributor for her honesty and bravery.

Among the positive reactions was that of ‘LN’, who said:

Thank you. It’s so hard to stand up to this kind of joke culture because if you don’t find jokes about rape and sexism hilarious, you’re deemed to have “no sense of humour”. It’s become so standard to joke about that people are worryingly blase about it. I feel that at a time in which sexual equality is quite a hot topic, we are taking huge steps backwards. And it’s not just men, before anyone brings up that old chestnut. Women are (foolishly) joining in, presumably so as to seem “chilled out” about the whole thing. Well, sorry, I don’t think sexual abuse is something we should really chill out about. 

Thanks for being brave enough to say what a lot of us have been thinking for a good while.

As well as ‘Middle Ground’, who echoed this appreciation:

Thank you. many times as I have heard students in Durham making comments about rape I have wondered how they would react if told that one of their female (or male) friends had been raped. I presume they would wish they hadn’t said anything. Given the rape statistics you quote, it would be better if everyone had a serious think before indulging in this kind of so-called “harmless” humor.

Another article which attracted attention was Justin Villamil’s piece on gender constructs and stereotypes. To this, Sigrid Holth commented:

…I agree with you, there really is no reason why genders should be divided as they are in Western society today. In my opinion, having only two genders is also very limiting. Take for example some countries in Asia, where they have up to five genders. How narrow-minded Western society looks compared to that… If I was a little girl again, I would be SO exited about the prospect of getting a toy dinosaur or a set of really awesome lego!

Thank you very much to our contributors for stirring up some debate. If you feel strongly about these or any other issues, and would like to write for us, don’t hesitate to get in touch. Keep your tweets and comments coming in!

UPDATE: 13/12/2012, 00.41am – Ben Hamer’s article on the benefits of typing in exams has also been tweeted by @ones_to_watch.