The Hobbit – a prequel too far?

Martin Freeman stars as the titular hero. Photograph: Warner Bros.

by Helen Sandford

There is always an uneasy anticipation when a much loved story is dragged back from its peaceful resting place. Delving into a story’s past seems an ingenious tactic to revisit these popular tales, but films such as Dumb and Dumberer: When Harry Met Lloyd have made us question: where should the line be drawn? Prequels do not have a huge success record and yet now Oscar winning director Peter Jackson is set to join the bandwagon with the soon to be released The Hobbit. The inevitable question now hangs in the air: will the film live up to its blockbuster predecessors?

Some might question this decision, but he managed to produce three amazing films that have gone down in movie history and there seems no reason why he cannot do the same again. Instead of basic retreads like so many a franchise, The Hobbit instead visits unchartered lands in Middle Earth. The perfect balance seems to be struck between beloved characters and new exciting additions to the plot; whilst there may be no more banter between Legolas and Gimli, there are thirteen feisty dwarves to entertain and enchant us.

Everything is pointing to it being an absolutely cracking Christmas blockbuster

The cast is certainly star studded; Cate Blanchett, Ian McKellen, Elijah Wood and the awesome Andy Serkis all reappear, while Martin Freeman and Benedict Cumberbatch take a break from the bleak London of Sherlock to submerge themselves in fantasy, set in the beautiful landscapes of New Zealand. Going by the cast, also including Richard Armitage in black leather once more after the BBC’s rather tame Robin Hood, there should be little question over the film’s success.

Excitingly The Hobbit will have two 3D options as the new 48 frames per second (fps) 3D technology is being showcased. Although this new technology is seen by many as a new landmark in filmmaking, the audience of an early preview were left less than impressed by the experience. It seems sensible then that Warner Brothers have advised against an extra charge for the 48 fps 3D tickets, which would have been expected since it requires a different type of projection. Perhaps this is due to the limited 48 fps 3D showings, or an attempt to promote the technology’s potential to the public.

Either way, many are still divided over the benefits, but if we are to believe Imax’s assurances that we will feel as if we are “in the movie”, what viewer would complain about being submerged in the glory and action of the battle scenes? And what woman would argue against being surrounded by fifteen or so enchanting men, wielding swords?

Andy Serkis returns as an old enemy. Photograph: Warner Bros.

Prequels are not the only way forward, but considering the wreckage of Indiana Jones, Rambo and Shrek, reviving a franchise does not always seem such a good idea. However with regards The Hobbit, it is less a case of trying to drag on an exhausted storyline, since JRR Tolkien wrote it before the Lord of the Rings trilogy, so the plot works specifically into the subsequent sequels. One needs only to remember the success of the Star Wars prequels to know that a planned, intended prequel is a successful way to carry on a loved franchise. Though now that Disney have taken over Lucasfilm the jury is out again over the resuscitation of the Star Wars franchise; it now seems inevitable that the films will follow the newly trodden path of the Bourne series, with new characters tenuously linked back to exhausted plotlines.

While The Hobbit is unlikely to have that problem, Peter Jackson has played with the plot, shifting focus onto Sauron and potentially over shadowing the main villain Smaug. Since few manage to struggle all the way through the LOTR books, changes to the plots in the films were hardly noticed, but The Hobbit is more widely read and audiences might take umbrage at this change in focus.

Nevertheless the technicalities of the script are unlikely to change the overall success of the film and with such a brilliant cast and setting, everything is pointing to it being an absolutely cracking Christmas blockbuster.

The Hobbit will be in cinemas from December 14th.