The Vice Chancellor’s Athenian Ideal

by James MurrayChris-Higgins-poor-quality

The Vice Chancellor’s recent pay rise is a bold statement that redefines the image of our university. Professor Chris Higgins saw his basic pay rise from £211,000 to £232,000 pa, an increase of more than the total salary of the lowest paid staff, meaning the pay discrepancy between his salary and average university pay is now 8:1.

The large pay rise is in part due to a shuffling around of pension contributions. Since last year anything over £1.5million paid into the ‘life allowance’ fund is ineligible for tax relief, which means that instead of paying pension contributions, many boards opted to give their vice-chancellors direct remunerations which cannot be ‘taxed out of existence.’

The pay rise comes after a two year pay freeze for Higgins, but at a sensitive time politically while most other employers are facing real-term pay freezes. But perhaps this shouldn’t come as a surprise; after all it is merely the latest in a long term trend to redefine the function of universities. The official reason given is that “outstanding performance requires exceptional remuneration.”

This is an interesting line of reasoning because it is based on the assumption that monetary incentive brings in the best people for the job. In a business, where the sole existence of the institution is to accumulate money, perhaps this holds more weight. But for an institution which aims at knowledge and education it is hard to overlook the irony between this view and the lack of any credible philosophies supporting the pursuit of material wealth as the basis for a good life. Even Adam Smith dismisses such a life philosophy referring to wealth as “trinkets and baubles.” So what interest does an esteemed academic such as our Vice Chancellor see in his trinkets and baubles?

The pay rise is merely the latest in a long term trend to redefine the function of universities.

To understand this, it is necessary to look more closely at the university culture, wherein there is an obvious discord. On the one hand there is the emancipatory dialogue of education and the pursuit of knowledge. On the other there is the status game of reward and competition.

A joke among politics students is that one is happiest when the others on the course are unhappy; but is this not a general, albeit tacit part of daily life at university? For example, does sympathising with somebody who’s failing not actually boost your own confidence? Or is it not often the case that somebody will explain something to you in a way which is completely confusing, using the pedagogical pretence to hide an (in)conspicuous competition? And is the culmination of this not an exam system which is directly competitive, directly relative to your peers as opposed to an absolute measurement against the subject matter?

This inconspicuous competition is the unspoken drive of university life. A comparison with the notion of conspicuous consumption might be useful. But whereas conspicuous consumption focuses on the having of a certain product for providing satisfaction, this inconspicuous competition focuses on the other not-having (of knowledge) to provide the satisfaction. In this way it functions negatively; that is to say, it feeds people’s success with others’ failures. In this discourse knowledge is used to discriminate and develop inequalities.

The reason for its complicity might be found in its antagonism with the other strand of university discourse. It is the great discourse of equality, emancipation, fraternity and dignity in the pursuit of knowledge; Pericles’ Athenian Ideal.  In this discourse knowledge is used to unite and create equality.

The VC’s pay rise attempts to unite these two strands of thought within the university by taking meritocracy to its logical conclusion; that is a justified, proud elitism. For what the university is becoming is a process for the stratification of people based on a perceived (and to an extent arbitrary, such as writing quickly in an exam) meritocratic ability and thereby assigning status, and the way this is reflected is by material remuneration; albeit a job with an investment banking firms, or a pay rise at the top.

The university image is neither the ‘New Age’ emancipatory equaliser, nor the corporate, ‘survival-of-the-fittest’ competition; it is a new age un-equaliser. We come here as equals and leave unequals. It is important to note that inequality here is not simply the material inequality; in a way that is inconsequential. The material inequality merely attempts to represent a much more essential inequality – that of status.

In this way knowledge assumes its fullest meritocratic function as the arbitrator of status. University is a status game where the prize is the prestige of Churchill’s pilots. For those recognised as the ‘indispensable’ talents in our society; never has so much, been owed to so few, by so many.