Gay marriage: a moral and political ‘no-brainer’

Gay Marriages NYC

by Thomas Dimaio

After witnessing the parliamentary debate and aftermath of the gay marriage bill, it seems that the issue had both a political and moral edge to it. The political problem centred on the damage this bill could do to the image of the conservative party ahead of the 2015 general election. The moral argument is one of equality and the meaning of the term marriage.

The political argument put forward by Conservatives who opposed the bill was that it would alienate voters. Indeed, there are some people who might have been alienated by the bill, but the number of voters who would have been appalled if the decision had gone the other way would certainly have been higher.

Numerous national Conservative groups have been highly supportive of the bill and for good reason. It could be argued that were it not for the American Republican’s frankly backward social policy, the party would have performed far better at the recent presidential election, and the same theory applies to our upcoming election: sticking to antiquated social legislation would have been equally damaging for the Tories.

One of the biggest criticisms of the Conservative party is that it needs rapid modernisation, and this is where the political debate becomes a moral one. Attitudes towards gay people in this country have thankfully come a long way in my lifetime let alone the lifetimes of those in my parents’ generation.

There is simply no rational reason to treat gay people any differently to straight people. We live in a liberal country with liberal values and to deny marriage to gay people harks back to a time when these liberal values were shamefully ignored. Nevertheless, if you include those who abstained, 176 Tory MPs did not vote in favour of the bill. Therefore we must endeavour to comprehend what possible moral reasons they would have to do this.

The most commonly referred to of these reasons is a religious one. Many religious groups are opposed to gay marriage for doctrinal reasons. Whilst their right to hold this view must be upheld at all costs, one must ask why religious opinion is being given so much weight in our parliament.

Indeed, a large proportion of religious figures have come out in support of this bill. If it had not been passed then the very same people who are rejecting it on religious grounds are, in doing so, preventing others from practising a ceremony that is entirely in tune with their religious beliefs.

Secondly, the ‘quadruple lock’ of laws put in place to protect religious groups explicitly states that under no circumstances will any religious official be forced to marry a same-sex couple. No religious rights are being put in danger because of this bill, thus there is no religious reason not to support it.

Other critics of the bill have pointed to the ‘meaning’ of the word marriage. This ‘meaning’ is intrinsically linked to the idea of one man and one woman –  a heterosexual relationship which is supposedly vital as it makes possible reproduction and is apparently the ‘best’ way of raising offspring.

Many children of divorced parents will argue that heterosexual marriage has had either no effect on their upbringing or indeed a negative one, whilst one MP made the important point that the ‘traditional’ meaning of marriage has been changed numerous times since state involvement in the ceremony occurred in the 1750s.

Indeed as recently as the 1990s it was a ‘traditional’ part of marriage that a man could rape his wife without it being labelled a criminal offence. I’m sure even die-hard traditionalists would agree that this change had to be made, so why the dilemma in changing another inherently negative aspect of marriage?

To oppose this bill was to oppose equality. It stops no one practicing their own beliefs but to vote against it stops same-sex couples and numerous religious officials from practising theirs.