The US and China: a tragic trade war?
By Nathan Beckett
Despite rising tensions between the US and China, trade between the two economies hit an all time high in 2022, with combined trade value totalling to £572.6bn in exports and imports across the year. Total trade value increased by around 5% from 2021, reflecting not only the effects of the cost of living crisis and COVID-19 but the “difficulties of […] decoupling” the two economies, as suggested by Deborah Elms, the founder of the Asian Trade Centre.
It has been five years since President Donald Trump first set tariffs to combat US dependency on Chinese imports and stop the outflow of US technology to Bejing. Yet, despite these efforts from US officials, it is becoming clear that the trade war between the two nations is not coming to a close anytime soon, with the 2022 deficit standing at $382.9bn, the second highest bilateral trade deficit on record.
It is becoming clear that the trade war between the two nations is not coming to a close anytime soon
All of this comes at a time when US-China relations are at an all time low following uproar over alleged Chinese spy balloons being discovered over US territory. In this case, why does the total US-China trade value and the US trade deficit remain so high despite increased tensions?
Ultimately, experts suggest that the economies are too entwined to detangle as quickly as was initially hoped in 2018. Secondly, rising inflation rates across the West has made it even harder for firms and consumers to resist cheap machinery and consumer products from China. Lastly, domestic resistance to cutting off trade to China remains high, with the largest share of exports to China being agricultural goods.
John Bode, the president and CEO of the Corn Refiners Assocication and a supporter of the Farmers for Free Trade Coalition, states that decoupling from China would be a “terrible mistake”. Instead of the end of multilateral free trade, Bode suggests to manage the US-China relationship so that “strategically sensitive information is protected”.
In light of the spying reports, the concern surrounding sensitive information is a matter that will certainly drive future trade relations. Despite these concerns, it does not seem as if the US is entirely withdrawing from China, nor does it seem that economic relations will improve anytime soon.
Going forward, it is important to acknowledge that the trade in goods deficit remains $35bn lower than when the trade war first began in 2018. From 2002 to 2012, the US goods deficit increased by around 306% during China’s rapid economic growth as a global superpower. Comparatively, the growth of the trade deficit has slowed significantly across the previous decade, increasing by around 122%. Although the trade war has not decoupled the two economies, the trend in trade figures suggest that the exponential growth of Chinese economic influence over the US has generally plateaued.
It seems likely that investors and firms may tread more cautiously in future trade relations with China
So, what does this suggest about the future of trade between the US and China? With the trade war becoming a matter of not just trade but domestic security and “sovereignty” as remarked by President Biden in his State of the Union speech, it seems likely that investors and firms may tread more cautiously in future trade relations with China. As such, many seem to be adopting a ‘China-plus-one strategy’ to diversify their options and minimise the effects of recent tensions, avoiding supply disruptions by moving production to less politically volatile countries such as Mexico, India and South East Asia. In fact, total trade between the US and Vietnam has tripled over the past decade, reaching $127.5bn in 2022. If relations between the US and China worsen even further, this trend may exponentially continue to increase.
Overall, the US has struggled to decouple from China for various reasons and the trade deficit remains high. Despite this, geopolitical tensions and concerns of national security will only further raise caution in future trade. Even if the two economies do not completely decouple, production and supply chains will certainly diversify in the coming years, with the Boston Consulting Group estimating a 10% decrease in trade with China through to 2031.
Image: ConexiónCOP Agencia de noticias via Wikimedia Commons

