The uncertain future of America’s death penalty
By Tom Gomes

There is a particular choreography to an American execution: a gurney, drawn blinds, and the clinical reassurance of protocol. Yet, on 30th September 2026, this choreography collapsed. Christa Pike, condemned to death for the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, was to become the first woman executed in Tennessee since 1820. Despite two doses of pentobarbital, Ms Pike continued breathing, her snoring audible to witnesses. While Tennessee’s protocol anticipates that the initial dose may fail, it is conspicuously silent on the failure of a second. Medical experts posit a potential misplaced IV line or ruptured veins, while Ms Pike’s lawyers believe that a lifelong clotting disorder – in which her body overproduces platelets – made her veins difficult to access. The cause remains unclarified. Consequently, Bill Lee, Governor of Tennessee, has since halted the state’s remaining execution of the year, and has ordered an independent review. Interestingly, Mr Lee’s rationale was administrative rather than moral: Tennesseans, he declared, expect sentences to be carried out in a manner “that is not only legal and constitutional, but is effective”. For Mr Lee, it is the procedure, not the principle, that stands trial.
Though Tennessee’s failure was shrouded in secrecy, the Pentagon’s ambition had been the opposite: maximum publicity. Earlier this month, US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that Nidal Hasan, the former Army psychiatrist convicted of murdering 13 people at Fort Hood in 2009, would undergo a firing-squad execution, and that it would be livestreamed: “No brainer: army major, betrays his country, radical Islamist, kills a bunch of Americans […] it hasn’t been since World War II since we’ve done that. Well, I kind of liked the mentality we had in World War II, which was win”, Mr Hegseth contended. Considering such remarks, Republican senator Thom Tillis has called the idea “beyond disgusting”, with Vice President JD Vance likewise disapproving of its coverage. Within a week, President Donald Trump had overruled his own Defence Secretary.
Is the death penalty, then, slowly becoming politically untenable? The national mood suggests retrogradation.
Taken together, these episodes coalesce to reveal a system less national than federal — a patchwork stitched together by 50 legislatures. Since the Supreme Court sanctioned reinstatement in 1976, each state has settled the dilemma itself: 27 retain capital punishment, while 23 have abandoned it. Retentionist states cluster in the South, a region historically marked by a legacy of racialised punishment and a high concentration of white evangelical Protestants. Abolitionist states, conversely, tend to be Democratic-leaning, and have a stronger Catholic presence, most notably in the Northeast.
Is the death penalty, then, slowly becoming politically untenable? The national mood suggests retrogradation. Since 1994, support for capital punishment has dropped 27%; more strikingly is the generational chasm, with fewer than half of Americans aged 18 to 54 supporting it, compared with 62% of those over 55. Yet, where Republicans govern, the practice is accelerating. Republican support has scarcely wavered in 25 years, holding above 80%; among Democrats, it stands at 32%. Executions nearly doubled between 2024 and 2025, propelled largely by Florida, where Governor Ron DeSantis presided over a state record of 19. In Washington, President Trump inaugurated his second term with an executive order instructing the Attorney General to pursue the death penalty. Consequently, in February 2025, Pam Bondi formally lifted the Biden-era federal moratorium — an administrative decision that put federal executions on pause – declaring, “this shameful era ends today”.
Whether a Democratic resurgence at November’s midterms would reverse this trend remains uncertain: Congress has no power to abolish capital punishment in the states, and any bill to end the federal death penalty would almost certainly be vetoed by the President. A Democratic Senate could slow judicial confirmations down, and, in time, influence how receptive the courts are to capital appeals, though this is far from guaranteed. Arguably more consequential are the 36 gubernatorial elections taking place alongside the midterms, since governors grant clemency, impose moratoria, and in some states, set the execution dates.
For now, the death penalty occupies a curious position in America: too unpopular to be broadcast, yet too popular to be abolished. Somewhere between the livestream and the drawn curtain lies an uncomfortable truth: the nation remains unsure whether it wishes to watch, or merely to know that it is being done.
Image Credit: U.S. Air Force Senior Airman Madelyn Keech

