Pomp and circumstance
By Tom Gomes
Once upon a time, Hollywood had a hairstyle: Cary Grant wore it, Clark Gable wore it, Rudolph Valentino wore it – hair swept back, lacquered into a greasy obedience, a coiffure that distinguished its subject as meticulous, straightlaced, soigne. Decades later, in what one may consider the most notable exemplification of pomp and circumstance, Leonardo DiCaprio, assuming the elusive role of Jay Gatsby, wore it. Today, however, hairstyles of such polish have become obsolete, forced to surrender to the modish cuts of the present. The cocktail glass, too, has made similar concessions. A martini once intimated sophistication; now, the modern student reaches for a pint (and for those determined to maintain a lofty air, Disaronno). Today, the conventions of old Hollywood are, admittedly, dissolving – besides one: the dinner jacket. In Durham, black tie has outlived the world that produced it, and its survival invites the question: what, precisely, are we wearing it for?
For some, the answer is uncomfortably simple – black tie dress is slowly becoming artifice: evenings curated more to be photographed than to be lived, their worth measured in the images that survive the occasion. The clothes, previously the uniform of a class, have become the costume of an aspiration.
Black tie dress is slowly becoming artifice
Durham students have, undoubtedly, earned their places at the University’s balls and formals through their academic distinction. Yet, sometimes, students slip into the role of Fitzgerald’s eponymous hero, as if the ballroom were the summit of a hard-fought ascent, rather than an evening purchased on (or with what remains of) the student loan. Yet there is an irony in this, one most people would either subconsciously suppress, or actively ignore: Gatsby himself was a fabrication – the invention of a young man who had constructed a ‘romantic readiness’ and then threw lavish parties just to sustain the façade. His decadence was never an authentic expression of his self; rather, it was a performance, tagged for an audience of one. To play Gatsby is, in turn, to imitate an imitation. Gatsby possessed both the means and liberty to burn through his fortune – hedonism, for him, was an expense easily endured. Few Durham students can enjoy such license.
And yet, once one crosses the threshold of Beamish Hall, beneath the chandeliers, casting their luminescence like a benediction, the resolve to remain authentic to oneself begins to fracture. The tension between staying grounded and humble, appreciative of spectacle without becoming consumed by it, and yielding, if only for an evening, to the seductive fantasy of personal reinvention reaches its most problematic. As Jay Gatz eventually realises: it is not wrong to want, it is wrong to believe that wanting could rewrite who you are.
To play Gatsby is, in turn, to imitate an imitation
None of this is to disparage Durham’s formal traditions: the balls and formals are a microcosm of an opulence that very few will ever indulge in outside the parameters of the university. Thus, there is a degree of generosity in the traditions that lends such grandeur, albeit ephemeral, to those who may not otherwise inhabit it once they have graduated. Nor should we overlook what these evenings do for the city itself. As gowns and dinner jackets drift across Palace Green, or fill the town’s bars, Durham is textured with a brief elevation, touched by a quiet mystique, whispering of ostentation and solemnity. Passersby pause, and fellow students watch and wonder, imagining that someday they, too, will be the object of this same exact gaze.
The gaze may be the truest thing about it all. Fitzgerald closes his magnum opus with Gatsby straining across the water, glaring once more at the cultural touchstone – that is, the green light. Durham’s glamour functions in much the same way: most luminous from a distance, a little dimmer up close, and no less worth looking at for that.
Image credit: Linnaea Mallette via Creative Commons

