The Ukraine War and the growing case for European unity
By Grant Kuppenheimer and Dan Bavister
In the forests near Donetsk in eastern Ukraine, where the scent of pine lingers alongside the acrid reek of burning metal, the earth bore witness to sacrifice. Beneath the skeletal branches of a tree, a young soldier lay still. Night came without a star, and in the darkness, only distant artillery flashes illuminated the scene. The fallen soldier was Vitalii Senchenko, a 22-year-old from Kryvyi Rih, a city in central Ukraine, located in the Dnipropetrovsk Oblast.
Vitalii’s journey had been marked by courage and sorrow. In 2022, he became one of the defenders of Mariupol, holding the line at the Azovstal steelworks in one of the war’s most harrowing sieges. Famously, he swam across the freezing waters of the Taganrog Gulf to join the resistance at the plant. His mother, Oksana Latanska, held onto hope through his captivity, receiving sporadic messages until silence became their only connection. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy would posthumously make him a Hero of Ukraine, the highest national title that can be conferred upon an individual citizen by the President of Ukraine. Vitalii’s story is not unique – it echoes the sacrifices of countless Ukrainians who have fought for their nation’s sovereignty, a seemingly eternal battle that has raged for centuries.
The name ‘Ukraine’ is rooted in the Polish word Ukrajina and an older Slavic term, both meaning ‘borderland’, reflecting its position on the frontier between Europe and Russia. Historically, after flourishing as the heart of the first major Slavic civilisation in the 10th century, the region endured a millennium of division and foreign domination. Only with the Soviet Union’s collapse in 1991 did Ukraine finally secure its independence. Strategically positioned at the nexus of East and West, Ukraine’s location continues to define its geopolitical significance and vulnerability. Today’s war is the latest chapter in a long struggle to assert its sovereignty in the face of external pressures.
Since Russia’s invasion in 2022, Ukrainians have fought relentlessly to defend their sovereignty. With Donald Trump returning to the White House, many fear they could lose their most crucial ally: the United States. Mr Trump has pledged to end US aid to Ukraine and end the war in 24 hours, though he has offered no details on how.
In Kyiv, reactions to Mr Trump’s election are mixed. President Zelenskyy congratulated him, emphasising their “great meeting” in September and praising Trump’s “peace through strength” approach, an invocation of Ronald Reagan’s rhetoric. Despite these public niceties, notable concerns linger. President Zelenskyy has criticised President Biden’s “overly cautious” policies, which he believes embolden Russia. Yet Trump’s admiration for Vladimir Putin, the architect of Ukraine’s current war, raises new anxieties. Among ordinary Ukrainians, there is a deep sense of unease. Oksana Tsupii, a 53-year-old trader in Kyiv, fears that Ukraine may be pressured into making territorial concessions.
“The European Union is behind Ukraine, but it is not clear if they can fill the gap if the US steps back”
“We are so small in this world of big politics. And unfortunately, our lives are worth nothing,” Tsupii told an American reporter at NPR, reflecting the helplessness many feel as global power dynamics shift. Despite this, others on the front lines remain steadfast. Andrii, a 35-year-old soldier who shared only his first name due to military protocol, underscored that Ukraine’s resilience won’t falter because of a leadership change in the US. “Look, if we have to adapt, we will do it. Our people have already shown so much resilience, so we will rely on our strength and our forces,” he said confidently.
However, challenges mount. Russian forces are advancing in the eastern regions, and Ukraine has confirmed that thousands of North Korean soldiers have now joined Russian ranks. Adding to the uncertainty, Mr Trump’s lack of support for NATO could jeopardise Ukraine’s aspirations for alliance membership, a critical factor for long-term security. While Europe remains a steadfast partner, there is concern that EU support alone may not be enough. “The European Union is behind Ukraine, but it’s not clear if they can fill the gap if the US steps back,” said NPR’s Joanna Kakissis, reporting from Kyiv. For now, Ukraine’s fate hangs in the balance, driven by both its own steadfast resilience and the evolving political will of its allies.
The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights further believes that 14.6 million civilians need urgent humanitarian assistance
It is hard to imagine another kinetic interstate war on the European continent. Still, for two years now the Russo-Ukrainian war has grinded on. It is easy to relegate this ongoing conflict to the back of our minds because it has attained a degree of normalcy in our day-to-day lives. We must resist this temptation, for war can never be equated with normalcy. Some figures should remind us of modern warfare’s sobering, destructive power.
According to confidential Ukrainian documents obtained by the Wall Street Journal, Ukrainian military deaths numbered 80,000 and over 400,000 wounded. Furthermore, Western intelligence estimates that Russian military deaths range between 70,000 and 200,000 and wounded at around 400,000. Two years since the beginning of Russia’s full-scale invasion, Ukraine has recaptured 54 per cent of occupied territory; however, Ukrainian counter-offensive efforts have stalled. According to the Council on Foreign Relations, Russia continues to occupy 18 per cent of the country, specifically Crimea, and parts of Donetsk, Kherson, Luhansk, Mykolayiv, and Zaporizhzhya Oblasts. The aggressor nation, Russia, has also opened a new front in the northeast Kharkiv region, and the belligerent continues to bombard Ukrainian cities and blockade ports.

To continue this fight, Ukraine has received about $278 billion in aid, including $75 billion from the US since January 2022. However, no conflict is able to prevent civilian casualties, and the conflict in Ukraine is no different. The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights verifies that 35,160 civilian casualties have occurred from 24th February 2022 to 31st July 2024. Further, the High Commissioner reports that 3.7mn people are internally displaced, and 6.5 million have fled Ukraine altogether. OHCHR further believes that 14.6 million civilians need urgent humanitarian assistance.
If Europe were once united … there would be no limit to the happiness, prosperity and glory its people could achieve
The conflict in Ukraine, marked by staggering human and territorial costs, highlights the ongoing struggle for sovereignty and security in Europe. As the war drags on, the international community faces a familiar challenge: how to achieve lasting peace amidst regional instability. This dilemma is not new. In the aftermath of the Second World War, Winston Churchill recognised that only through unity and co-operation could Europe prevent further devastation.
In the aftermath of the Second World War, Winston Churchill championed the idea of a “Union of Europe” to ensure lasting peace and stability. In his famous speech at the University of Zurich in 1946, Churchill called for European unity, emphasising the need for Franco-German reconciliation: “If Europe were once united … there would be no limit to the happiness, prosperity and glory its people could achieve.” He saw co-operation as essential to preventing future conflict and containing Soviet influence in the emerging Cold War.
Churchill’s vision took shape at the 1948 Congress of Europe in The Hague, which laid the groundwork for the Council of Europe in 1949. His ideas also influenced the creation of the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) in 1951, a precursor to today’s European Union. While Churchill believed in a strong, united Europe, he famously stated that Britain should remain “with Europe, but not of it”, reflecting the UK’s focus on its global empire and close ties with the United States.
Though Churchill did not envision Britain as part of a European federation, his advocacy for unity inspired key figures such as Jean Monnet and Robert Schuman, who turned his vision into practical steps towards integration. His legacy remains foundational to the European project, which continues to strive for peace and co-operation across the continent. However, his perspective also embodies the complexity of the project in a British context: “with Europe, but not of it” is a philosophy that has captivated the contemporary Brexit movement led by Nigel Farage and others on the Eurosceptic wing of British politics.
Ukraine has received about $750 billion in aid, including $75 billion from the US since January 2022
With the signing of the Maastricht Treaty in 1992, the foundational work for a more integrated European economic and political community became a reality. Indeed, we witnessed the forging of a new Europe for a new millennium. With the collapse of the Soviet Union, it appeared all of Europe would be united under a democratic mandate for the first time in history. However, the financial crisis of 2008 and the migrant crisis of 2012 proved tumultuous for the young Union. Central bureaucratic decisions by Brussels were not well received by all member states, and the clamour for reform echoed louder.
By 2016, the vision of a unified Europe did not match the reality of a diverse spectrum of member states. A lack of notable reform provided the perfect opportunity for British Eurosceptics to question the project altogether. With the shocking outcome of the 2016 referendum, the UK instantaneously set itself on a different trajectory. The country became unmoored politically; it was unclear what place post-Brexit ‘global Britain’ would have in the world. With a similar populist movement electing Donald Trump in 2016, one wondered if the UK preferred Washington over Brussels.
Now that the positive momentum of the European project seen in the early 2000s is in question, how do we juxtapose the populist rhetoric seen in 2016 with the re-election of Donald Trump and Sir Keir Starmer’s UK general election victory in 2024? Despite the US choosing to return to Mr Trump’s ‘America First’ agenda, maintaining scepticism towards international co-operation, the UK electorate appears to desire the opposite. Indeed, Labour’s historic victory illustrates the growing awareness of the byproduct of populism and a wish for greater co-operation with the European Union.

So much has changed since 2016 for the Brexit and MAGA movements alike, one cannot understate the lasting changes a new Trump administration will have on US foreign policy. Mr Trump’s affinity for protectionism and a reduction of overseas commitments — especially in Europe — further cements the transition to a multi-polar world. While it remains unclear if the 47th US President will decisively pull out of NATO — the 32-member American led defensive alliance established at the end of the Second World War — it is probable that the US government under Mr Trump will re-examine continually supplying Ukraine with military matériel. Since January 2022, Ukraine has received about $278 billion in aid, including $75 billion from the United States. Many American Republicans feel such support — two years on — ought to be re-negotiated.
As concerns mount over the future of US support for Ukraine, much of the uncertainty revolves around the re-emergence of Mr Trump as a prominent figure in US politics. Mr Trump’s ‘America First’ stance continues to position the US as an increasingly isolationist power on the world stage. His repeated criticisms of NATO and past indications that he might curtail foreign aid raise alarms for Ukraine, which has depended heavily on US assistance since Russia’s invasion in 2022.
To ‘Trump-proof’ Ukraine’s funding from NATO, European allies, in collaboration with President Biden’s administration, have long been working to ensure that military and financial support to Ukraine remains steady, even in the event of a change in US leadership. With concerns that a second term for Donald Trump could significantly reduce US aid, NATO has been exploring ways to take over the coordination of military support to Ukraine, effectively shifting leadership from the U.S.-led Ukraine Defense Contact Group, established in April 2022. This would allow NATO to provide more predictable and robust assistance, which is crucial to Ukraine’s security given the unpredictability of US political dynamics, especially considering Mr Trump’s re-election.
NATO’s strategy includes discussions about creating a multi- year financial commitment, with a potential $100 billion fund to support Ukraine over an extended period. By institutionalising this support within a NATO framework, European leaders hope to ensure continued assistance, regardless of shifts in US policy. The goal is not only to provide Ukraine with the resources it needs but also to send a strong message to Russia that NATO’s commitment to Ukraine remains unwavering.
The Russo-Ukraine war … is an existential threat that would force greater intergovernmental co-operation
Despite this rather gloomy outlook, President Emmanuel Macron seemed to foresee a long-term divergence between American and European political goals. According to statements by the president to the European Parliament in May 2022, Mr Macron noted the emergence of a ‘multi-tier Europe’, in which European countries represent mixed degrees of integration with the EU, some adopting the Euro and Schengen border agreement, others opting out and a minority of countries (Norway, Switzerland, Iceland, and the UK) remain outside the EU altogether. The French president opted to create a “European Political Community”, a club to foster co-operation between the EU and its neighbours.
While this plan appears ambitious and ambiguous, Mr Macron presents three rationales outlined by the Centre for European Reform in August 2022. First, it is believed that the EU’s neighbourhood policy has largely failed. The vision of Commission President Romano Prodi in 2004 did not offer sufficient incentives for EU candidate countries to embrace the reforms the EU desired for membership. The second rationale is the largely stalled process of EU enlargement; countries in the Western Balkans, Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine have all been stuck in the EU’s antechamber for two decades. It is unclear if they will ever get out. Third, there remains a perception in Paris that more ought to be done to ‘socialise’ the British into greater co-operation outside of official EU channels. Mr Macron desired a forum for all governments — regardless of their status with the EU — to discuss geostrategic concerns, especially regarding Russia. Despite this encouraging alternative vision for Europe, much of Macron’s plan was met with mostly negative reactions from many Central and East European countries, let alone by the EU itself.

However, the situation in 2024 is vastly different; one would be foolish to dismiss such a concept, especially on the grounds of collective security. The Russo-Ukraine war — aided by a second Trump administration — is an existential threat that would force greater intergovernmental co-operation. Macron’s 2022 vision explicitly called for creating a ‘European Security Council’, including the UK. While this was envisioned as more of a forum to discuss strategic goals, one wonders how Europe would respond to the void created by an absent American leadership in NATO.
While the American lack of confidence in NATO is worrying, some in Europe feel such weariness is a forgone conclusion that has been building for some time. In that case, Ukrainian survival depends on the success of Macronian philosophies on a European political community and the kickstarting of a regional military industry. Such a vision appears to be the only scenario encapsulating all democratic European countries, bypassing Brussels. The immediate goal would be countering Russia and supporting Ukraine, the threat of a wider European conflict being exacerbated by a speedy withdrawal of American support. The European community must rise to this challenge and prepare to bear the brunt of Russian aggression.
As dawn breaks over Ukraine’s battle-scarred landscape, the golden domes of Kyiv catch the first light, standing resilient against the shadows of war. Across Europe, from Paris to Warsaw, a quiet urgency awakens — a call to honour the sacrifices of those Ukrainian forces who gave everything for freedom. The re-election of Donald Trump, far from signalling abandonment, offers Europe its most opportune moment. This is Europe’s chance to lead — not in the shadow others but as a beacon of resolve. The winds of history are shifting, and the Europe of tomorrow must stand firm, ready to meet the storm and build a future where unity and peace prevail.
Feature image: President of Ukraine via Flickr Image 1: Alex Kent via Flickr, Image 2: Simon Dawson via Flickr, Image 3: Identity via Flickr

