The ugly expectations of femininity in sport
By Isabel Cridland
The beginning of July may signify the start of summer, but more importantly it brings the pinnacle of the annual tennis calendar, Wimbledon. The nation becomes gripped by Andy Murray’s quest to win a second Wimbledon title, accompanied by copious quantities of strawberries with cream and glasses of Pimm’s. For a keen tennis player and devoted fan, Wimbledon provides two weeks of unadulterated tennis. However, this year in particular, tennis was not the only discussion. No, I am not alluding to the BBC’s deplorable revamp Wimbledon 2Day. Or the warmest Wimbledon on record. It is the continuing debate regarding female athletes and femininity.
Although Serena Williams has long been victimised for her muscular build by individuals and commentators alike, her historic achievements were rather overshadowed by such offensive remarks. Throughout the tournament, Twitter was awash with comments focusing on Williams’ appearance. One particular tweet saying that “Serena looks like a man” was met with a fitting retort from J. K. Rowling. The insults are not unusual, with Williams subject to much image-related criticism during her career; for instance, the President of the Russian Tennis Federation, Shamil Tarpischev, described her and sister Venus as the “Williams brothers”.
Yet, on the eve of the women’s singles final, the New York Times chose to publish an article focusing on Williams’ physique. Despite the World Number One being on the brink of completing a second non-calendar year Grand Slam, an achievement which would further cement her status as part of the tennis elite, analysing the prospect was evidently an unworthy news story. Instead Williams’ tennis prowess was rather ignored in favour of an article which suggests her muscles are not attractive or feminine. Such views generate insecurities amongst tennis players, with Andrea Petkovic disclosing her repulsion when seeing pictures of herself hitting two-handed backhands, when her arm muscles appear the most bulging. More distressingly, Agneizka Radwanska’s coach revealed her team “keep her as the smallest player in the top 10 because first of all [Radwanska’s] a woman, and she wants to be a woman”. Sportswomen should not have to choose between being strong and being women. They should be respected for their outstanding athleticism as strong women.
The archaic principle of femininity creates expectations which extend throughout women’s sport, where women are assessed by their image rather than athleticism, somewhat explaining the reluctance of some women to involve themselves in sport. Females are expected to live up to society’s specific gender roles and demonstrate “feminine” qualities such as gentleness, fragility and vulnerability. Not only are women commonly steered towards less aggressive sports, they are expected to perform differently by maintaining femininity. Rather than appreciating Williams’ powerful groundstrokes and recognising her as an athlete who has excelled in her sport, Williams is identified by her muscular frame which makes her less conventionally feminine and beautiful.
Unlike their male counterparts who are purely rated on performances, female athletes are also defined by their beauty and sex appeal. Two years ago when Marion Bartoli triumphed at Wimbledon, instead of praising Bartoli’s incredible athleticism and fighting spirit, John Inverdale made his infamous comment that she was “never going to be a looker”. The ‘woman first, athlete second’ mentality means achievements are often sidelined, as the double Olympic swimming champion Rebecca Adlington can testify, turning to plastic surgery to achieve society’s demands of ideal beauty. There is immense pressure to live up to these standards; after winning the Women’s Singles at Wimbledon this year, Williams succumbed to criticism regarding her natural eyebrows, posting a video of her eyebrow waxing and letting the “#haters” know they won. No one took issue with the Men’s Champion’s eyebrows. Society needs to learn to appreciate sportswomen for their athleticism and ability, and reverse the ‘woman first, athlete second’ outlook.
However, the media does not facilitate the discouragement of this mentality. The sex appeal of female athletes takes precedence over their athletic prowess, denying their legitimacy as professional athletes. Anna Kournakova epitomises this troubling trend, famous because of her physical attractiveness and scantily clad magazine appearances, despite never winning a major tennis tournament. Still, by allowing herself to appear in suggestive poses and revealing clothing, she has perhaps not done herself or the legitimacy of sportswomen any favours, although the strong encouragement and pressure to prioritise their sexual attractiveness should not be underestimated.
Regardless of the setting, sportswomen’s images are nevertheless focused upon. Despite Eugenie Bouchard’s fantastic on-court endeavours, her terrific win at the Australian Open this year was overshadowed by the on-court interviewer asking Bouchard to “give us a twirl and tell us about your outfit”. Together with the sexualisation of sportswomen, such deriding of a female athlete’s achievements should not be tolerated, especially when compared to the upmost admiration male counterparts receive for their performances.
The disparity between genders is further shown by the endorsements the top players obtain. In men’s tennis, the most successful athletes on court generally collect the most in endorsements. However, in the women’s game, endorsements tend to reward physical attractiveness. Whilst Serena is undoubtedly the top women’s tennis player, with 21 grand slams and countless WTA titles, the less successful player Maria Sharapova earns $22 million in endorsements, compared to $11 million by Williams, according to Forbes. Receiving double the endorsements of a player who has thrashed her 18-2 in their career head-to-head confirms endorsements reward the most attractive players, according to the perception of Western beauty.
Sharapova is tall, thin and blonde, epitomising the classic white model appearance. Serena is black, possessing an African-American athletic physique. Williams is often described as a “gorilla” or “ape” on social media, and is subject to more appearance-related criticism than other female tennis players. This reiterates the point that there should be less emphasis on appearance, including race, and more focus on athletic achievement. Endorsements should reward the best players so they can reap the rewards of hard graft on the tennis court, and make the situation more comparable to the men’s game.
Focus on sportswomen’s attractiveness rather than athleticism only serves to deprive them of legitimacy as professional athletes. With constant scrutiny and concentration on females’ body image, something not helped by the media accentuating the sex appeal of sportswomen over athletic ability, there is a worrying reluctance for players to push themselves to achieve their full potential, for fear of losing the feminine qualities society expects them to maintain. Society has to start demanding that athletic ability prevails over Western beauty ideals. Attractiveness and femininity should not be a concern, with sportswomen being respected for their exceptional athleticism as strong women.
Photograph: Katherine Shann, via Wikimedia Commons

