Private vs state: do our top universities still favour the educationally elite?
By Kate Dean
The battle between state schools and private schools re-emerges every year in the aftermath of A-level and GCSE results days. 2015 was no exception, and comparisons have been drawn between both types of institution, with state schools surpassing fee-paying schools in individual students’ A-level results. Research based on figures provided by the Department of Education demonstrates that the top 500 state schools have beaten the top 500 private schools in England.
Although the comparison has been deemed unfair, the narrowing of the gap between elite schools and state schools is refreshing and bodes well for an increase in the equality of our educational system as those unable to pay fees are able to receive high-quality teaching in free schools. However, the sense of elitism in top English universities such as Oxbridge, Durham and Bristol does not appear to be dissolving. Whereas only 3.1% of national university first-time degree entrants in 2014 were private school educated, 42.5% of Oxford first years were from private school, 39% in Cambridge and 25% in Durham.
These figures demonstrate a lack of change in the traditional elitist models used for the selection process by our top universities. If the gap in results is narrowing, why are such a huge percentage of private school educated students attendees at elite institutions? More worryingly, the number of state school educated first years at Cambridge University fell in 2013/14. Of course, such universities claim that their application process favours the most suitable students, regardless of their upbringing or school. However, such suggestions are hard to believe when reading reports from the Sutton Trust, which suggest that five elite schools and colleges send as many students to Oxbridge in one academic year as 1,800 state schools put together.
Perhaps, then, the process of getting into top universities doesn’t just come down to the grades. Private schools have better facilities to support numerous extracurricular activities, which, as we have all been told numerous times, make us more interesting in the application process. Moreover, private schools have more time, money and resources to offer interview preparation and entrance exam coaching, something many state schools are simply unable to do. Such advantages demonstrate an elitism which extends beyond the curriculum, and the existence of private schools has been criticised as allowing advantages to some children based simply on the family they were born into. On this basis, should private schools be abolished altogether?
Recently, David Cameron announced that his children would be attending a state school – clearly an attempt to disparage his own extremely affluent background that allowed him to attend Eton, and to demonstrate a trust in his own state-run system. But there are state schools and state schools, right? Elitism within the education system, of course, is deep-rooted and extends beyond those schools that require parents to pay fees to attend. Grammar schools and other exclusive state schools also create controversy concerning the injustice of the quality of education received by children based on their social class or area of catchment. The catchment areas of top state schools are filled only by those who can afford to live there, many prestigious schools are filled with children whose parents provide tuition to help them pass the 11+, and grammar schools are not even available in many areas of the country.
What I’m trying to suggest is that educational inequality extends beyond the private-state school divide, a divide that appears to be narrowing in terms of results. We can abolish private schools and this may solve some of the problems regarding entrance to top universities: however, a hierarchy of state schools also exists, and more needs to be done in order to allow all children equal opportunity.
Photograph: Sandwell Council via Flickr

