The Student Loans Controversy

By Daisie Mackay

The issue of student loans has once again been thrust into the spotlight, with the unfairness of the system being critically re-examined. Among increased reporting and commentary, Parliament has begun to weigh in, with 20 Labour MPs criticising “rip off” interest rates, and the Leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch, describing the system as a “debt trap” for graduates. With increasing cross-party criticism, the government has come under fire for its perceived lack of reflection on reforming the system, from campaigners like Martin Lewis to those graduates suffering from this system themselves.

Those currently bearing the brunt of the effects, graduates on Plan 2 student loans who started university from September 2012 to July 2023, have their loans written off after 30 years if they are not paid back. However, the rate at which these loans are growing is ballooning, with compounding interest rates and the freezing of repayment thresholds in the government’s 2025 Budget, dubbed a “stealth tax”. Graduates are finding that their debt has grown far larger than the loan they originally took out, and are angry at having bought into this system presented as just another tax on their income, when the reality they face is far more dire. A Plan 2 graduate must earn at least £66,000 per year just to make their debt go down, something detractors such as Labour MP Jas Athwal have argued especially disincentivises middle-earners from striving for career progression. Other critics also accuse the government of forgetting the economic contribution graduates make; because they tend to have better career prospects following university, graduates pay higher income tax which brings in more revenue for the Treasury. The argument goes that graduates are already giving a significant amount to the Treasury: so why are they being penalised for having the opportunity to do so?

With this dilemma, a raft of reforms has been proposed. The Conservatives want to reduce the maximum interest rate graduates are repaying at, which the IFS reports, while having significant benefits for higher-earning graduates, would not be so kind to those on lower incomes, as well as having no immediate effect on current monthly repayments. The Green Party and even several Labour MPs are calling for tuition fees to be scrapped altogether, though with the current funding crisis many universities are struggling with, this proposal is one the government is unlikely to consider. 

”The argument goes that graduates are already giving a significant amount to the Treasury: so why are they being penalised for having the opportunity to do so?”

Another popular proposal backed by the Liberal Democrats and many in the Labour Party is to raise repayment thresholds, which would benefit those lower-to-middle earners, allowing them to save around £14,000 altogether. Given, however, that the government has just frozen said thresholds, this again seems unlikely, though with the number of U-turns the current government has made when under political pressure, such changes would not be completely out of character.

This issue is especially pressing for the government given their poor performance in the polls; they really cannot afford to be losing more support, something most visibly seen in their recent loss to the Green Party in the Gorton and Denton by-election. This has been hailed as groundbreaking by many commentators saying it shows the Greens are now seen as a credible alternative to Labour, putting the government in an evermore precarious position. From controversy over winter fuel payments with older generations to Personal Independence Payments for disabled people, Labour’s voter base has been continuously haemorrhaging support, and adding this extra dimension of unhappy graduates is sure to exacerbate their spiralling unpopularity. 

Historically, the Labour Party has done well among graduates, but many young people in this demographic are getting sick of their needs constantly being ignored, particularly when so many policies appear, to them, geared towards the older generation. While this may be electorally beneficial to Labour due to older peoples’ higher electoral turnout, Labour may be in for a nasty shock if they do not solve this issue with those that have long been at the core of their voter base. While the Prime Minister is to “look at ways to make it fairer”, there is a fear that the issue of student loans has for too long been ignored, and any reform will not be without huge costs for the government, whether financially or electorally.

Image: ƒliçkrwåy via Wikimedia Commons