The Sound of Corruption
By Alfie Whillis
In 2019, being an amateur music critic is easier than ever. Rate Your Music, an entirely free-to-use community-built database of music, boasts over 600,000 members actively reviewing and discussing the latest releases. Reddit pages catering to genre-specific communities have tens and even hundreds of thousands of subscribers. Internet personalities like Anthony Fantano have given hope to the aspiring critic that their opinions are valid and that there is an audience out there for them. Any discerning music fan can publish their opinions on a forum and receive feedback almost instantly from fellow fans around the world.
The annual announcement of nominations is met with a barrage of criticism, most recently accusations of sexism and racism
Meanwhile, the Grammys continue with their annual celebration of a music industry in decline. Without fail, the annual announcement of nominations is met with a barrage of criticism, most recently accusations of sexism and racism. This year’s list of nominations lays bare the Grammys’ conflict of interest: trying to represent the best new music, allowing the 12,000 members of the Recording Academy to pick, and trying to keep the nomination list representative of different musical cultures whilst maintaining television appeal. Recording Academy President and CEO Neil Portnow described this year’s nominations as ‘incredibly relevant and on point’, and whilst the Grammys may have challenged accusations of a racial and gender bias with an impressively diverse list of nominations in the General Field categories (Record Of The Year, Album Of The Year, Song Of The Year and Best New Artist), for another year running the list fails at its primary purpose of being a collection of the best new music.
The issues with the Grammys largely stem from its voting system. Entries are screened by experts who decide whether they fit the genre they’ve been entered in. The 12,000 voting members of the Recording Academy then cast ballots to decide the nominees and the eventual winner. The final result of this process does not present the best albums of the year, but rather the most mainstream.
Whilst the Academy discourages members from voting in categories outside of their expertise, this is an unenforced guideline. To become a member of the Academy, you need 12 credits on releases and 2 referrals, so the membership is largely comprised of an older generation that are less likely to be familiar with new music. So, when members come to vote on a category in which they are unfamiliar with many of the nominees, they often just vote for the most well-known artist on the list.
They often just vote for the most well-known artist
In a reveal-all article on Complex, a member of the screening committee for the Reggae category revealed an unwritten rule amongst committee members: ‘be careful about green-lighting an album by someone who was really famous if you don’t want to see that album win a Grammy’. This is confirmed by looking at past winners of the Reggae award; 6 of the last 10 awards went to members of the Marley family, often beating out far more critically acclaimed albums.
Releases that lack mainstream appeal and artists that aren’t household names, particularly those from a minority background, are less likely to win. Frank Ocean’s characterisation of the Grammys as a “dinosaur that doesn’t represent young, black artists” seems appropriate.
Why would I ask the music
industry executives when I can
ask fellow music fans?
Recent attempts to diversify the voting members by allowing online voting to encourage younger members to vote and inviting more women and people of colour to register might begin to rectify these problems, but ignores a greater problem. The Grammys are not awarded based on musical merit or even on sales figures, but on the opinions of often-uninformed music industry insiders, and if the winners are decided by the opinions of laymen that raises the question: why do I care what they think? If I want to know what the best new music is, why would I ask the music industry execs when I can ask fellow music fans? The voting system for Rate Your Music is remarkably similar to that of the Grammys, letting any registered member rate albums they’ve listened to. The scores are aggregated and ranked. Rather than attempting to take a snapshot, reducing the year down to one album per genre, the site allows scores to change as opinion changes over the years. None of the Grammys 8 picks for Album of the Year appear in RYM’s top 50 of 2018.
The Grammys are not awarded
based on musical merit or even
on sales figures
The Grammys may have its place as ‘Music’s Biggest Night’, a television spectacle and a chance for the music industry to socialise, but it is not a celebration of the best new music. Maynard James Keenan of Tool described the Grammys as ‘the music business celebrating itself’, and if the Grammys wants to regain some relevance perhaps it just needs to embrace that. For now, let’s stop celebrating the middle-man between artists and audiences, and start celebrating interesting, innovative new music. So if you find yourself in front of the TV watching the ceremony, why not turn it off and go online to see what people really think?
Photo via Flickr by Twitter Trends 2019
