The Science Behind the Gender Gap
By Cameron Lang
It is no secret that women are massively underrepresented in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) subjects. A report from the UK Government Equalities office found that women make up 46 per cent of the UK’s workforce, but only 15.5 per cent of the STEM workforce. What could possibly account for this huge disparity? Are there really that many fewer women interested in STEM subjects?
A study by UC Irvine found there is almost no difference in intelligence between men and women, but found significant differences in the brain areas in which males and females manifest their intelligence. Men had more grey-matter, and women more white-matter. The former is responsible for processing and retrieving information whilst the latter is responsible for transmitting instructions to the body and grey-matter.
“These findings suggest that two evolutionary pathways have created two different types of brains designed for equally intelligent behaviour” said Richard Haier, who led the study.
This may help explain why some men are more likely to chose careers that require more local processing, such as maths, and why some women tend to excel in careers that require more integrating and assimilating information, such as required for language facility.
However, most interestingly, this difference does not affect scores for general cognitive ability, explaining why men and women still have similar IQ scores with little variation.
However, this difference in brain structure may not necessarily translate to better results during school studies. A meta-analysis of research published in the American Psychological Association showed that from primary school to university level there was a small but significant female advantage across all subjects. The study incorporated results from 1914 through 2011 and included more than 30 countries. What was most fascinating was that the female advantage was largest for language courses, and the smallest advantage was in mathematics, supporting the previously mentioned study.
This suggests that even though male brains are perhaps slightly more inclined towards STEM subjects, women are still outcompeting men throughout all levels of education in STEM subjects. So, why are more women not pursuing careers in STEM subjects?
Previous studies have shown that in general the choice of a STEM career hinges on a high mathematical ability and a relatively lower verbal ability. In a study by Jeffrey Valla and Stephen Ceci, they discuss how males are more likely to have an asymmetrical cognitive profile (a proficiency in maths does not also correspond to a proficiency in verbal domains). Whereas females tend to have more symmetrical cognitive profiles, capable with maths and verbal communication. Therefore, women perhaps have more conflict when deciding to commit to STEM subjects since they are just as proficient in other areas of academia. This perhaps broadens their career choices and could be an underappreciated reason why fewer women are in STEM subjects. A more productive approach of increasing gender representation is to clarify to talented women that diverse career paths are available within STEM.
We must not also forget to look at many other important factors that may contribute to the gender gap. Gender bias and a potentially sexist culture may be to blame in some STEM environments. Not too recently Nobel prize winner Tim Hunt told a room of high ranking scientists that the problem with ‘girls’ working in science is that “three things happen when they are in the lab… You fall in love with them, they fall in love with you and when you criticize them, they cry.” Whether this was meant seriously or not, comments such as this are hugely influential to many young students and perpetuate a culture where some women perhaps feel unwelcome and less likely to chose a career in STEM subjects as a result.
Unconscious gender bias in the classroom may also be a factor – at a teaching level, in science and maths the majority of role models are men, which could affect young girls in not seeing a future in STEM careers.
There are many factors that have contributed to the gender gap in STEM careers, perhaps some aspects are simply unavoidable and some I have not mentioned. Nevertheless, more should be done in schools to encourage women to pursue careers in STEM; a change of culture, emphasis on more female scientists as role models and showcasing that there are diverse STEM career opportunities.
Photo Credit: Creative Commons
