Political ideology is the biggest threat to Britain’s railways
By Danny Walker
The summer of 2016 was tumultuous for British politics. On June 23rd, the U.K. voted to leave the EU, ending its 43-year association with the political and economic bloc. We then experienced a change in leadership with Theresa May replacing David Cameron as Prime Minister, as well as much of his administration. Finally, both the second- and third-largest parties by vote share in the 2015 general election, Labour and Ukip, undertook particularly gruelling leadership contests. George Eaton had a point when he argued, writing in the New Statesman in July, that 2016 is ‘one of the ruptures…the UK is given roughly every 35 years’.
Yet one policy area has stimulated debate just as frequently as our EU membership: our trains. Britain’s railways face two competing but blinkered ideologies, which manifest in calls for nationalisation or privatisation. Jeremy Corbyn has renewed left-wing, ‘nationalising’ approaches to public transportation, which effectively cites ‘government’ as the panacea for all ills – inefficient services, strikes over pay and rocketing fares. But Corbyn was recently undermined by his ‘Traingate’ video debacle, in which he exaggerated the extent of overcrowding on a mid-morning East Coast service. In the face of evidence which suggested overcrowding is a time-specific problem, Corbyn chose to generalise and misrepresent his situation in order to advance his ideological cause: more government to ‘fix’ our railway crisis.
The Conservative Party are no better. Today’s neo-Thatcherites are poles apart from Corbyn’s Labour; yet like the Left, the Right are driven deeply by ideology. The Tory-led coalition highlighted their dogma with the privatisation of the East Coast (EC) main line. East Coast actually generated a profit for the taxpayer under public ownership, albeit with the convoluted system whereby government subsidises Network Rail (NR), the operator, directly, thus reducing EC’s contributions to NR. Nevertheless, the profit enabled the government to charge more affordable fares and mitigated the Department of Transport’s contributions to the national budget deficit. In addition, East Coast had a far-from-stable governance under past private operators GNER and National Express – they both cancelled their franchises for financial reasons, evidence which debunks the right-wing argument that privatisation always raises efficiency. Virgin has operated the franchise since 2015, administering two fare rises this year. The second, 1.4% in September, was described as ‘blatant profiteering’ by Middlesbrough MP Andy McDonald. So the government would ostensibly rather taxpayers and commuters were worse off than suffer the ignominy of running public transportation.
Why do this country’s main political parties, unfailingly ideological in method, continue to attract such support? Perhaps it is a wider symptom of the death of ‘centrist’ politics. A balanced approach to public transportation between private and public railway franchises is not being articulated. Therefore the public must lend their support to the position with which they broadly agree with and oppose that with which they broadly disagree. But from a governing perspective, surely it is important to consider whether public or private franchises, or some combination of the two, are most effective in each individual case? Theresa May’s decision to permit the £24.3bn takeover of ARM holdings by SoftBank of Japan, early in her Prime Ministership, has been argued to illustrate her ‘case-by-case [and interventionist] approach’ to privatisation. (George Eaton, July 2016). But then again, as Private Eye (19th August-September 1st edition) revealed in August, her government awarded the contract to build 63 carriages for the Great Western rail franchise to Hitachi, a Japanese company operating in Italy – even after David Cameron had trumpeted the work as good for ‘local…highly-skilled manufacturing’ in Derby!
Moreover, Cameron’s misrepresentation of reality, just like ‘Traingate’, indicates the way in which both parties portray their own ideas as orthodox and moderate, whilst their opponents are caricatured as extreme ideologues. This merely worsens the division of voters into polarised camps, viewing the other as the enemy, with whom they cannot compromise; in turn, the parties respond with yet more ideology. This catch-22 creates simplistic, unsolvable debates in the public sphere: with such competing, rigid principles, no one can be happy with the compromise. Theresa May’s government has a lot to do to abate this process.
Ultimately, the public deserves a more rigorous, evidence-based approach to issues like rail than what the main two political parties currently offer. The East Coast affair illustrates the Conservatives’ commitment to privatisation at all costs, whereas Corbyn proposes allowing all private licenses to expire and eventually renationalise, which will be expensive and require major structural changes. Is this policy indiscriminately appropriate for all rail franchises? We need an approach that considers the nuances of the situation, such as exactly why some franchises are more profitable than others, and the significance of time of travel to public and private profits. We need an approach that recognizes that better-off consumers can benefit the economy, as can profitable private train companies, so long as they do not charge exorbitant fares. We need an approach that tackles, not stigmatises or celebrates, the sensitive issue of strikes over pay.
The subject of our railways only occupies a segment of mainstream political discourse. But this debate is significant because it illuminates the ideological limits to solving the biggest and most urgent problems of our day. Jeremy Corbyn faced a leadership challenge because he was seen as insufficiently defensive of the EU. Yet critics on the right also condemned him for having not ‘stuck to his principles’ of opposing further EU expansion as an MP since 1983, refusing to accept that his position had to change on becoming Labour leader. Michael Gove’s claim that ‘this country has had enough of experts’, preferring instead ideology and emotion, was the icing on the cake. A less ideological and more evidence-based, rational and pragmatic politics would benefit society. But do the political elites or indeed the body politic itself seek this change? It may seem anachronistic to call for moderate, compromising politicians in an era where the public appears to loathe the ‘PR’ image such individuals project – but this may be just what this country needs.
Photograph by Tejvan Pettinger
