The Russian-Ukrainian War: The Newest Threat to the United Nations Security Council
By Luca Colson
As of June 2023, the Russian Federation’s invasion of Ukraine, which began on February 24th, 2022, has accumulated an estimated 8,983 civilian deaths according to the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. The United Nations Security Council, composed of 15 member states, 5 permanent (United States, United Kingdom, France, China, and Russia) with the right to veto resolutions, and a further 10 elected states, is responsible for preserving international peace and security. Due to the invasion’s illegitimate nature, in addition to ever-increasing military and civilian casualties, public attention has converged towards the Security Council’s response to the crisis, or lack thereof.
The legitimacy-threatening effects of this war, as a result of the Security Council’s response, is not unique in the institution’s history. Rather, a multitude of crises have occurred during which the Council’s ability to fulfil its mandate has been hampered. Indeed, the Russian-Ukrainian War is the most explicit representation of the Security Council’s deficiencies, as Russia, a permanent, veto-wielding member with the power to prevent substantive resolutions from emerging, is the perpetrator of the conflict in question. This newest crisis has only intensified criticism of the institution amongst the international community, political commentators, and academics. The Council’s legitimacy, and future are thus cast in doubt as it becomes increasingly empty and void of its righteous purpose.
The Security Council has long been plagued by severe flaws that have led to tragedy. Crises have emerged from operational errors, or ineptitude. For instance, the Rwandan Genocide of 1994, accounting for approximately 800,000 casualties, occurred as the Council simultaneously reduced the number of peacekeepers operating in Rwanda. This error, as well as a refusal to categorise the atrocities as a genocide, delayed any substantive reactions and initiatives.
The Security Council has increasingly become crippled by great power contests, previously a characteristic of the institution during the Cold War period.
However, the Security Council has increasingly become crippled by great power contests, previously a characteristic of the institution during the Cold War period. The most notable example of post-Cold War rivalries in the Council concerns the Syrian Civil War (2011-present). Two opposing coalitions have formed preventing crucial resolutions from being adopted: on one hand, the United States, United Kingdom, and France refuse to rule out the possibility of direct foreign intervention; on the other hand, Russia and China have vetoed resolutions that did not outright take forced regime change off the table.
The adverse impact of great power interests on Security Council decision-making has become all the more important as Russia is directly involved in the condemned invasion. Their delegation is thus able to veto any resolution that threatens Russian interests. It came as no surprise that the Russian delegation did not hesitate to use its veto when its aggressive acts were called into question.
Subsequently, a first UN Security Council resolution draft, submitted on February 25th, 2022, condemning Russia’s actions, and asking its government to remove all troops from Ukraine, was vetoed despite support amongst both permanent and elected members of the Council, in addition to China’s non-veto abstention. A second resolution condemning Russia’s attempted annexations of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Eastern Ukraine was also swiftly vetoed by Russia on September 30th, 2022. The veto power accorded to the permanent members of the Council has veiled Russia from any UN-sponsored operations, or legally binding sanctions. Thus, a dangerous precedent has been set in stone: veto-wielding states are immune to the worst of Security Council consequences when violating the sovereign rights guaranteed to fellow state’s by the United Nations Charter.
The accumulation of Security Council failures caused by great power rivalry-induced deadlocks has inspired calls for reforms on the use of the veto, and on permanent-member accountability. As a direct response to Russia’s perpetual attempts to protect itself, the UN General Assembly, a forum of all 193 UN member-states, implemented a resolution in April 2022 to hold permanent Council members accountable for their use of vetoes. Within 10 days of a veto’s deployment, the General Assembly is to convene to discuss the specific case, while the veto-deployer is expected to justify its use. This initiative is an important first step in increasing the Council’s transparency; however, the institution and its permanent members have little reason to deviate from their ‘common’ behaviour in the absence of a truly effective deterrent.
The Russian Federation’s invasion of Ukraine has created a new threat to the Security Council’s legitimacy as the primary guarantor of international peace and security. The Council is increasingly perceived as a tool used by great powers to protect and promote their respective interests. Whilst the veto has always been used from its inception for this very reason, for the first time, it has been used by an aggressor state to shield itself from substantive, multilateral retaliation. While the General Assembly has attempted to hold the permanent Council members accountable, the precedent of great powers shielding themselves via the veto has been set, paving the way for similar outcomes in the future. The Security Council, its functions, its legitimacy, its future, and the mission to maintain international peace and security are all under threat.
Image: MusikAnimal via Wikimedia Commons
