The royal state visit to France : toward a warming of Anglo-French relations?

By Axel Gaugain

King Charles III and Queen Camilla flew to France on September 20th for their first state visit to the country since their coronation. Initially planned in March, this visit was postponed due to riots against Emanuel Macron’s pension reform. Following a weakening of anglo-french relations since Brexit, what does this state visit mean for the relationship between the two nations?

Tensions peaked under Boris Johnson’s premiership. In an interview given to the French daily, Le Monde, the former UK ambassador to France considered the post-Brexit years to be “the worst of the bilateral relations I experienced in the forty years of my career”. 

Brexit has been the bone of contention between the two historical allies since the referendum in 2016. Indeed, as Theresa May fought to strike a deal with the EU, a number of Conservative MPs blamed France for supporting a firm position within the EU. Issues such as the issuing of fishing licenses to French boats took on symbolic weight in the way in which relations were hashed out post-Brexit. 

The former UK ambassador to France considered the post-Brexit years to be “the worst of the bilateral relations I experienced in the forty years of my career”. 

Conflict over the control of immigration across the Channel has further inflamed Anglo-French communications. In 2021, Boris Johnson’s public request to “take back” migrants crossing the sea-border from France provoked an outcry. The French government denounced Mr Johnson’s comments in a letter stating his statement had been “insufficient in its content and misplaced in its form”. 

King Charles insisted on the closed links between France and the UK 

In this context, King Charles III insisted on the historical ties linking France and the United Kingdom, affirming in a speech before the Senate that “the United Kingdom will always be one of the closest French ally and friend”, while the French presidency laid the emphasis on “the depth of the historical links uniting our countries”. 

In his speech, King Charles also stressed the importance of a close partnership to face global challenges such as the Ukrainian War and climate change. Hence its proposition to establish a “Cordial Agreement” on climate issues, echoing  the ‘Entente Cordiale’, a 1904 agreement which ended the colonial disputes between France and the United Kingdom, and laid the first stone of their future alliance during the Second World War. 

This state visit takes place as Anglo-French relations warm 

Even if these statements appear symbolic, they nonetheless took place in a longer phase of warming relations. In March, the first Anglo-French summit since 2018 allowed the two countries to make a fresh start : “a new beginning, an entente renewed”, according to Rishi Sunak. 

Furthermore, concrete agreements have been found to begin resolving some of the long term points of contention. For example, the United Kingdom unblocked 541 million euros to help French coastguards in their patrols against immigration across the Channel.

These rapprochements have been made easier by recent events, notably the war in Ukraine. For that matter, affirming his wish of a Ukrainian victory, King Charles stated that “our alliance is more important than ever”. 

In March, the first Anglo-French summit since 2018 allowed the two countries to make a fresh start : “a new beginning, an entente renewed”.

Furthermore, politically speaking, whereas Emmanuel Macron maintained bad relations with Boris Johnson, the French president has found in his successor Rishi Sunak both a serious interlocutor and a fellow. Indeed, the two leaders have a common  background in finance and an unusually young age. 

Toward a strong and steady Anglo-French allianc ? 

Now, the question is whether or not the positive intentions of King Charles will give rise to a pacified and stable relationship. Even if Charles III pledged himself to “make his best to reinforce the indispensable relation between the United Kingdom and France”, the ball is in Rishi Sunak’s court. Will he transform symbols into action, or prefer the status quo of minimal bilateral cooperations, as they are since Brexit ? 

Hindrances do remain. For Alice Billon-Galland of the Chatham House think tank, the current divergence between France and the United Kingdom is not in diagnosis, but in means : “while France, europhile, aims at developing the european strategic autonomy, the United Kingdom bets on NATO and its proximity with the United States”. Ultimately, the monarchy’s pacifying visit to France will not have erased five years of tense relations, but it does symbolize some of the more moderate tendencies in the British Government, choosing to move on from the isolationism of the early Brexit years.

In 2024, France and the United Kingdom will celebrate the 120th anniversary of the ‘Entente Cordiale’, an anniversary that could be an occasion to further take stock of their relations.

Image: Foreign, Common Wealth and Development Office via Flickr