The rise of fascism?
Please read the views below carefully, so thay you don’t misconstrue my intentions.
A list of BNP members has been leaked, and the anti-fascist campaigners are having a field day. Reports of threatening phone calls and job losses are already coming through.
The consensus on the BNP is that it is crypto-fascist: it is really fascist, but it pretends not to be. The basic facts as I see them are these: the BNP grew out of a nationalist movement which was comfortable expressing violent, racist, and particularly anti-Semitic, views, and elements of which enjoyed a sympathy with Nazism (beause of the the unity of the populace, the emphasis on discipline and order, for instance). This sympathy expresses itself as a cavalier and contrarian attitude to the crimes of Nazi Germany, and the employment of neo-Nazi symbolism and so forth. But now all that has been rolled back: under the leadership of Nick Griffin, the BNP discourages those elements of its nationalist constituency. I don’t say that it expels them, because it doesn’t. The reason it doesn’t is not because Griffin really thinks Hitler is great: it is because Griffin understands where such attitudes come from (namely, from wanting to give two fingers to the ‘liberal elite’) and is therefore not so condemning of such individuals.
My argument on the status of the BNP is simply that there is already a great deal of dissensus entailed by ‘moderate’ nationalism (for instance, closing the borders to immigration, encouraging – but not forcing – repatriation of recent immigrants). The whole attitude of nationalism is deeply cynical about human nature, and requires us to believe that human beings are safest and happiest in a monoculture. I don’t agree with it at all. Unlike the BNP, I don’t agree with it in its Zionist form, either. Given that there is such potential for argument here, why miss the opportunity? Why say that all this nationalism is just a cover for fascism? I understand why people think that it is, given the facts outlined above, but even if that analysis were correct, surely all the support that the BNP has gained since its philosophical shift under Griffin reflects the facade, not the central, secret fascism. (Otherwise, there would be no point in making such an image-transformation.) Which means that the anti-fascist supporters barring individuals on the leaked list from jobs, etc., are taking this action on the basis that those individuals belong to an organisation which has duped most them into believing it is not a fascist organisation, (though it really is – do you follow?).
In summary, the anti-fascists are taking action against the livelihood of individuals for their political allegiance to a political philosophy. If that philosophy genuinely were extremist, violent, racist – then there would be a debate to be had about the proper way to treat those who subscribe to it. But it isn’t. What’s happening and will continue to happen following this leaked information really does resemble fascism. At any rate, it certainly isn’t democratic.
