Behind closed doors
I’m not all that interested in Max Mosley’s sex life, but I was interested to see his attack on Paul Dacre in The Guardian recently. The background is that Dacre (the editor of the Daily Mail) gave a speech condemning Mosley’s victory in court as bad news for press freedom (Mosley sued the News of the World following their release of hidden-camera footage of his German-themed sado-masochistic orgy).
Mosley ask what grounds Dacre has for thinking it reasonable for a newspaper to ruin a man’s reputation in this way?
“The reason Dacre offers is “morality”. He tells us the newspapers must uphold decent moral values. But whose morality? Dacre does not seem to realise that modern Britain is home to myriad religious, ethnic and cultural groups, each with its own morality. How can the law be other than neutral, or as Dacre has it, “amoral”, between them? The courts are there to uphold the law, not to give force to a particular set of values.”
Behind the Daily Mail’s moral crusades – whether it’s the Ross-Brand affair, or Peter Hitchens’s ramblings against Darwinism, or Melanie Phillips tirades against ‘Londonistan’ – is, at least, a distaste for moral relativism. For Mosley, morality seems to be nothing more than the exotic plumage of minority groups.
I seem to remember Johann Hari in The Independent calling Mosley a “freedom fighter” and citing the trial of Oscar Wilde as a precedent for Mosley’s court case. Mosley doesn’t miss this trick either: “Dacre’s misplaced moral outrage reminds me of the prejudices once targeted at the gay community, not least by the Daily Mail.”
Well, I personally am not that happy to have gay rights being considered the analogue here. The reason is that the adjective ‘homosexual’ can apply to love as well as sex. I don’t think you can say that for ‘sado-masochist’. It was always the distinction which the bigots refused to make. Now relativists like Mosley, and I dare say not a few gay pride enthusiasts, can’t see the difference either.
