The Rise and Fall of PMQ’s: tenuous future for Commons debate forum

By Joss Greenfield

During Prime Minister’s Question Time on Wednesday 7th February, the Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak, made a now-infamous blunder while criticising Sir Keir Starmer’s multiple “U-turns”. Mr Sunak remarked that the Opposition Leader’s changes of approach included “defining a woman – although, in fairness, that was only 99% of a U-turn”. The comment refers to an interview with Sir Keir, where he stated, in relation to a debate around what defines a woman, that 99.9% of women “of course haven’t got a penis”.

Within the context of the recent sentencing of the murderers of transgender teen Brianna Ghey and the presence of Brianna’s mother, Esther, in Parliament on the 7th, the PM’s comments have been considered highly distasteful.

Mr Sunak’s comments on the 7th were defended by a spokesperson who suggested that it was “totally legitimate” for Mr Sunak to bring to light a series of U-turns in the Opposition’s policy. PMQs is designed as an opportunity for the Opposition and other MPs to scrutinise the PM and his government. This controversy arguably calls into question the utility and integrity of PMQs as an institution.

There is too much party political point-scoring

Created in 1961, Prime Minister’s Questions enable a medium for the Prime Minister to be held directly accountable by MPs and ministers, who can ask weekly questions about policy, government action and current events. However, PMQs have arguably been reduced to a spectacle, with MPs such as Jess Phillips and Chris Bryant openly criticising it as “political theatre” or “pantomime”. The public appears to agree with this sentiment as an Ipsos survey found that 67% of people agree that “there is too much party political point-scoring instead of answering the question”, and only 12% agree that PMQs “make me proud of Parliament”.

Though the electorate and MPs alike decry the state of PMQs, there is significant potential in the institution of PMQs if it is utilised correctly. It is not just valuable but critical that the Prime Minister and their government be held accountable and that their actions should be scrutinised publicly. Since Margaret Thatcher set a precedent in 1979, PMs answer all questions asked during Question Time rather than attempting to avoid questions by saying it is not under their remit and transferring responsibility to another minister. Thatcher’s reform should result in greater accountability, but in reality, other practices have emerged, such as ‘softball’ questions. These are easy questions from MPs or ministers seeking to gain the PM’s favour by providing some respite from more substantive questioning.

Examples of such ‘softball’ questions can be found in almost every critical piece written about PMQs. But even during PMQs on 7th February, when Mr Sunak made his blunder, the PM also answered questions such as “Does my Right Honourable Friend agree that Aneurin Bevan will be turning in his grave over the fact that we cannot trust Labour with the NHS?” (Conservative MP Alun Cairns). This question refers to healthcare issues in Wales, a devolved matter that ought to be discussed in the Senedd. Questions that appear to bolster the PM while criticising the Opposition arguably defeat the purpose of PMQs and misuse time for what should be substantive questioning.

This platform no longer effectively fulfils this function

As questions during PMQs are largely asked spontaneously rather than submitted beforehand, it is difficult to filter out ‘softball’ questions. Perhaps more extensive guidance to discourage this practice would help create PMQs that are more conducive to meaningful scrutiny.

However, there are other barriers to effective PMQs. Since the first filming of Question Time in 1989, the PM and the Leader of theOpposition have increasingly utilised it as an opportunity to create short ‘sound bites’ that distil their party messages so they can be easily quoted and disseminated by themedia. For example, Mr Sunak used MP Cairns’ question to criticise waiting times and education rates in “Labour-run Wales”, which he refers to as evidence that “we should…not go back to square one with Labour”. 

Mr Sunak’s barb regardingU-turns and defining women was also intended to be one of these ‘sound bites’. This notion is particularly convincing within the ‘culture wars’ discourse, which is speculated to be a salient issue in the upcoming General Election. Though his comment was particularly ill- received, all attempts to make such ‘quotable’ remarks arguably reduce the quality of debate in PMQs and diminish public perception.

This situation is also partly the fault of the press for hyper-fixating on these comments. There has been a slew of articles from the BBC, The Guardian, The Telegraph and countless other publications regarding Mr Sunak’s intentions and Sir Keir’s response, among various other aspects, including whether Mr Sunak should apologise and any potential Labour weaponization of the scenario. Such fallout only legitimates and encourages this style of PMQs: providing a platform for politicians to further personal attacks rather than focusing on the conduct of their job in representing their constituencies and governing the country.

PMQs were intended to facilitate detailed, meaningful questioning of the Prime Minister. As this platform no longer effectively fulfils this function, extensive reform could be necessary to prevent PMQs from continuing their possible spiral into meaningless political point scoring. While envisioned as a powerful platform to hold the Prime Minister to account, today PMQs has become little more than a means of scoring ephemeral partisan points.

Image: UK Parliament via Flickr