A council revolution? Labour’s plan to overhaul local government
By Joss Greenfield
When Labour was elected in July, they promised to enact a ‘devolution revolution’ which would empower local government bodies by decentralising power from Westminster. However, following the release of a written statement by Jim McMahon, the Minister for Local Government and English Devolution, in mid-December, it seems like this policy may not have the intended effect.
Devolution is the process by which Westminster delegates power to regional governments. For example, matters such as healthcare and education in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have been devolved to corresponding National Assemblies, meaning policy relating to, for example, Covid-19 and tuition fees has varied across the UK. The creation of these regional Assemblies was a response to nationalism and anti-unionism, particularly in Scotland, where nationalist sentiment has typically been strong. The devolved bodies thus give the regions greater independence from Westminster, and a greater degree of authority over their own affairs. Devolution within England was initially low priority, as 543 Westminster seats are English, and Westminster is considered already to adequately represent English interests.
Where English devolution has taken place, it has been in the form of Metro Mayors, though representation is not uniform across the country. It is this lack of uniformity and perceived failures of the current system of local government that Starmer’s policy aims to amend.
The plan has been met with disappointment from elected mayors who were hoping for more radical change, and horror from local councils who are being stripped of their authority. Overall, the policy seems confused in its aims. To simplify the discussion: The current model of district and county councils overlapping in many areas across the country will be replaced by unitary authorities to simplify government. Then, some more economic freedoms are being given to mayors, who will oversee a number of these new unitary authorities. So, while power is being decentralised from Westminster to some extent, more is actually being taken from local councils to pad out mayoral powers, in order to make the policy appear like a more radical decentralisation than it actually is. This may explain the negative reception of this proposal by councillors and elected mayors alike.
The proposed ‘rewiring’ intends to increase economic growth through the “uniquely placed” position of mayors. Mr MacMahon describes this unique position as a platform suited to “[tackling] the obstacles to growth that need a regional approach”.
Regardless of how effective this initiative proves to be, this shifts responsibility for economic growth away from Westminster. The economy was the central concern for voters in the 2024 election, and various economic failings by the Conservative Party during their tenure were used to justify ousting them. There will always be more than one motive behind policy and while it is nice to believe these are solely produced for the betterment of the country, the aim of most politicians is re-election. After all, you don’t get much of a say in policy at all if you’re not in power.
Milan Radulovic is a harsh critic of the government’s devolution plans, stating that “the current proposals of super councils is nothing short of dictatorship.”
Further evidence that the Labour might not have local government agency at heart is found in their recent clashes with Broxtowe Borough Council. The borough’s Labour councillors have clashed with the PLP over the winter fuel policy which cut winter fuel allowance for some pensioners. 20 councillors left the Labour Party and alleged that they had been blocked from standing for Labour in upcoming elections. This perhaps suggests that the Labour government is not meaningfully engaged in prioritising the concerns of local government. Among the councillors leaving Labour, Milan Radulovic is a harsh critic of the government’s devolution plans, stating that “the current proposals of super councils is nothing short of dictatorship.” Though quite an extreme perspective, as elected mayors would still be chosen by their constituents, the Ministerial directive attached to the white paper which would allow Westminster to impose unitary systems on communities that don’t want it perhaps reinforces the notion that local government and community voices are not necessarily the priority of this policy.
Overall, while it may be beneficial to somewhat centralise local government so regions can be more effectively advocated for at a higher level, achieving this by abolishing some of the most local forms of government, rather than actually devolving more power from Westminster is misleading. It seems as if they are in fact ‘taking back control’ away from local government.
Image credit: Rcsprinter123/Wikimedia Commons

