The reprint of Mein Kampf will help us to understand the legacy of Nazism
by Matthew Williams
Friday 27th January saw the 12th annual Holocaust Memorial Day in which many across the country joined together to remember the six million Jews who died due to Nazi brutality. Plans by a British publisher to reprint Mein Kampf (My Struggle), Hitler’s masterpiece of hateful excess in Germany, in the same week, unsurprisingly caused a stir.
Such a controversial act inevitably raises many questions regarding the balance between sentimentality and investigative historiography. It goes without saying that as a society we should commemorate those who died during the Holocaust, that we should have respect for those who survived and that we should do all that is necessary to prevent such a detestable crime from reoccurring. The question is which of these points is most important to us today?
Understandably, the reprinting of a book which vividly expresses Hitler’s anti-Semitism and in which elements of the Holocaust are set out, is seen by many as highly insensitive. More importantly, it is seen as completely unnecessary. This could not be further from the truth.
The reprint is a series of short booklets of excerpts of Mein Kampf followed by in depth analysis, by renowned historians. It is not simply another copy of the same text which is already widely available in well known bookshop chains around the world. Neither is it a reprint which promotes Nazism and anti-Semitism. In fact, it is the opposite.
Historical commentary allows Hitler’s writings to be further scrutinised. In so doing it allows a greater understanding of National Socialism (Nazism) and puts it in its historical context. Understanding here is key. If we cannot fully understand why these horrible crimes occurred then how can we possibly prevent further genocide in the future? It is often overlooked that since the end of the Second World War there have been many further genocides across the world. They may not have been on the same scale as executed by the Nazis but this does not in any way diminish their significance. Understanding why genocides occur and the prejudice that leads to them is essential. Even in the New Year there are still threats of mass killings for religious, racial or ethnic differences in Syria and Nigeria, as well as elsewhere around the world.
Since repeats of the Holocaust still threaten us today, it seems ridiculous to attempt to stop efforts for further understanding of it. Yet, this is exactly what the Bavarian state government is attempting. The government claims that the reprint violates the copyright of Mein Kampf which is in its ownership. There is no doubt that for Germans, the issue of links to their Nazi past is contentious. But surely enough time has elapsed to allow the freedom to fully explore this dark époque of their past.
By not discussing Nazism and in this case by not discussing Mein Kampf, Nazism is made a taboo, which fails to reveal the extent of its evil. Yes, many Germans supported the Nazi regime but this does not mean that they were evil people. The book is an example of the incredibly effective Nazi propaganda. By exploring it and publishing the findings, historians will be able to gain a greater understanding of and show why Nazi propaganda was so successful in enabling to them to commit mass murder.
For historians, as for journalists, the freedom of expression and information is paramount. Of course, a balance must be found between what is in the public interest and what can therefore justify upsetting many people, and what cannot. There is no doubt that this is one of those times. The insights which could be provided through exploration of Mein Kampf far outweigh the hurt that could be caused.
The Holocaust was the worst genocide in human history and occurred in a thoroughly modern developed society. The hateful and evil ideology of a minority was able to permeate an entire nation through propaganda and fear. This was a society of people who were no less intelligent or gullible than any others of the period. By playing on people’s prejudices and intolerances, the Nazis were able to commit the mass slaughter of millions of human beings. For this reason, we owe it to all the people who were killed to understand this event, so that prejudice and intolerance can be eradicated, or at the very least controlled.
Want to react to Matthew’s article? Comment below or tweet us @PalatiComment

