It is the inalienable right of the Falklands to remain British

by Matthew Williams 

Self-determination: the right of a country to choose its own government. A right upheld by the United Nations. A right vividly demonstrated by the Arab Spring and the continued violence in Syria. A right which the Falkland islanders possess but which the Argentinians are determined to ignore.

That a British Prime Minister should accuse Argentina of colonialism is ironic. Cameron’s comment last month was entirely justified considering Argentina’s retrograde attitude to the Falklands. While nostalgia for the Empire inevitably influences strong Tory support for the Falklands, the fact remains that the majority of the Falkland islanders are of British descent, and want to remain British.

It is right that Argentina’s continued pressure for talks on the issue of the islands sovereignty are repeatedly rebuffed, as there is nothing to discuss. If there was even the tiniest amount of support for Argentinian control on the islands then it would be a completely different story, but there is not.

American support for these talks is unwarranted and certainly adds to the diplomatic tension between Britain and Argentina. American help in the Falklands War in 1982 was invaluable so this apparent volte-face surely calls into question our ‘special relationship’.

Continued trade restrictions on the isolated islands by Argentina and its South American allies only make the situation worse. In fact, rather than encouraging talks and a closer relationship, Argentina has caused the Falklands to become closer and closer to Britain. The Argentinians are a cause of their own growing frustration while the issue in Britain at a public level, is relatively low key and even unknown.

Prince William’s arrival on the islands as part of his RAF duties last week and the sending of the elite destroyer HMS Dauntless to the region, unsurprisingly enraged Argentina. While the Foreign Secretary iterates that this is merely routine, this apparent military posturing gives Argentina far more ammunition. This militaristic approach certainly gives the Argentine government more public support, with polls showing around 70% support for its Falklands policies.

With the justified argument of self-determination, the British government has no need for any other action. Further action only serves to promote the Argentinian cause and gives it more global recognition. The approach of the 30thanniversary of the Falklands War, inevitably brings into focus the most recent conflict over the islands. But it seems highly unlikely that Argentina would resort to military action, as it would be rightly condemned internationally and would be greatly damaged as a developing country, as it was in the aftermath of 1982.

Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner

Why is Argentina so obsessed with the Falklands? With the recent re-election of Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner who enjoys strong support as president, the claim to the Falklands has been at the forefront of Argentinian foreign policy. Public support for the issue is growing. While Argentina maintains a historical claim to the islands, it was Britain who established the only permanent settlement on the islands in 1830. The exploration for oil by a British company in 2010 resulted in accusations of theft of Argentina’s natural resources.

Understandably, the prospect of there being millions of barrels of oil in the British Falklands territory renewed support for the Argentinian claims. As a developing nation such resources would be incredibly useful and provide a large economic benefit. The Falklands has a limited economy of mainly sheep and fish, so the discovery of oil is welcomed by many, but not by all.

The establishment of an oil industry in the region would require the building of much infrastructure to store, refine and transport the oil. As the Falklands are renowned for their spectacular wildlife, in particular for its millions of penguins, such a project causes some disquiet. Argentina is far better placed to develop this industry but refuses to even consider a joint oil venture. With global oil reserves on the decline the potential of this region is enormous. It is no surprise that there is tension between Britain and Argentina over this issue.

This does not change the Falkland islander’s right to self-determination. The problem for the islands is that they are likely to become more and more isolated. Argentina’s allies and other countries in the region are also unhappy at the prospect of a British oil industry. For many it is seen as a repeat of the imperial exploitation of foreign resources. This is simply not the case.

It is the Falkland islanders who would benefit most from an oil industry. Cooperation with other countries in the region especially Argentina would bring potentially great prosperity to all. This is unlikely to happen as long as Argentina continues to ignore the islands right to self-determination and their desire to remain British.

What do you make of Matthew’s argument? Comment below, or tweet us @PalatiComment