The reduction in sensitivity for influence

Content warning: this article contains discussion of school shooting.

By Hollie Bullen

Far-right conspiracy theorist Alex Jones has just been ordered to pay a combined sum of $965 million to the families of the victims of the Sandy Hook school massacre after he was the defendant in a defamation case that he lost. The plaintiffs brought a case to trial against Jones and his business as he alleged the 2012 school shooting, in which twenty-six people were tragically killed, was a hoax. This disgusting rhetoric is obviously false- but that did not matter to Jones’ followers, who have been lapping up his lies as truths for years.

In fact, Jones’ whole audience is built from his web show and his website- aptly named ‘Infowars.’ That is where he spouts his conspiracy theories and misinformation — his tirade against facts. He had a viral video a few years ago where he proclaimed that chemicals in the water are “turning the freaking frogs gay.” When confronted with a statement just as ridiculous as that many people, including myself, would just scoff at the insanity, and scroll on. But we need to do better at assessing the real danger people like Alex Jones pose to society. They attract a following: they make it possible for people to swarm together, lower their respect for others, spew hateful rhetoric, and attack innocent victims. The plaintiffs in the previously mentioned defamation case testified that they have been sent death threats online and harassed in person by Jones’ followers. This reduction in people’s sensitivity can create a safe space for people’s hatred to foster. This is how we end up with apps like Parler, in which the 6th January 2021 insurrection was planned. A reduction in sensitivity online can have a drastic impact on our sense of safety.

We need to do better at assessing the real danger people like Alex Jones pose to society

It’s not just the conspiracy theorists that use other people’s suffering for media attention. Whilst nowhere near as extreme as Alex Jones, and the insurrection, much of the content on social media has reduced our sensitivity to shocking things. Take the true crime community for instance: while some creators do try their best to be sensitive, there is no denying they are monetising other people’s trauma for their gain. I can’t imagine going through the pain of losing a loved one, only to see it rehashed on my timeline but with an audible sponsorship attached. There is no way you can be fully sensitive and respectful of victims and survivors whilst simultaneously making money off them. Even if your videos aren’t monetised, or you aren’t taking sponsorships, you are still drawing fame and an audience based on events that haven’t happened to you.

Recently, Netflix have just released a new TV series about Jeffery Dahmer. It is one of many in an extensive line of serial killer drama retellings, this time with Evan Peters staring as Dahmer. The family of Errol Lindsey, one of Dahmer’s victims, has come out and said that they were never consulted by Netflix about the making of this show and that it was “retraumatizing.” I understand the morbid curiosity surrounding true crime, but I just can’t seem to justify it especially when Netflix have made some great drama shows about fictional serial killers. For example, their hit thriller TV show “You” has a fourth coming out soon. Surely a show must be popular if it warrants a fourth season! I don’t understand the need for Netflix to have brought out yet another series about real tragic events, when they have other fantastic fictional stories in their repertoire.

All attention is good attention

This desperate grab for attention has had adverse effect on people. I genuinely believe it was not the intention of Netflix, or any true crime creator to re-traumatise people but that does not negate the fact it happened. In fact, not only have these stories disrespected the people involved they have normalised hearing about violent crime. The boost in popularity means nothing but money to an uncaring greedy algorithm and they get pushed out further. If I have learnt anything from being force fed drama on my timeline, it’s this: all attention is good attention. Even if it is someone rightfully responding to an Alex Jones tweet criticising him, it is boosting his engagement in the algorithm — and he knows it. No matter the intention behind posting about other people’s trauma, whether to raise awareness of a victim, or to encourage hatred — it is all treated the same by the algorithm. That is why we could do with gaining back the sensitivity and respect that has been lost along the way.

Image: Jaredholt via Wikimedia Commons