Are young people to blame for poor financial decisions?

By Hollie Bullen

TV shows about houses have been family staples since they first aired. They created an environment of escapism, allowing the viewer to critique the questionable interior design choices of the owner, without having to actively think after a long day at work. They were an easy watch and relatable to many, with housing and accommodation being high priority for a lot of people. Location, Location, Location was not an exception. 

First airing in 2000, Location, Location, Location follows a new set of buyers each episode as they attempt to find their dream home in their ideal location. However, they aren’t alone in this task. They are joined by experts Phil Spencer and Kirstie Allsopp, who along with providing personality to the show are available to provide advice and find suitable properties. Allsopp has recently come under fire after suggesting that if young people were to cancel their Netflix subscriptions and gym memberships that they would be able to afford to join the property ladder. 

This statement is drenched in hypocrisy. As people have pointed out, Allsopp was able to buy her house at the age of 21 with help from her family. What is important to note, is that her dad is Charles Allsopp, sixth Baron Hindlip, who was a member of the House of Lords. Sure, she didn’t have a Netflix subscription, but then I’m not related to a Baron. This leaves me to question; how much does she think a Netflix subscription is? 

Good news for first-time buyers from 1712 BC  â€” they’ve finally saved enough to join the property ladder!

The average house price in the UK is ÂŁ268,349. A Netflix subscription is ÂŁ5.99 a month. It would take someone 3,733 years to save this much money from cancelling a Netflix subscription. Good news for first-time buyers from 1712 BC  â€” they’ve finally saved enough to join the property ladder! 

In all seriousness, joining the property ladder has become impossible for first time buyers. It is hard to save for a deposit when you are spending 30% of your monthly salary renting. Less than 30% of millennials own a home before the age of 30, compared to 50% of baby boomers. It’s not hard to see why. Wages are stagnant whilst house prices have increased by 78% since 2000. 

According to LSE, the number of rental units owned by private landlords in the UK in 2014 grew by 125% in comparison to 2000. There are fewer houses available, driving up the market value of those still available. 

To paint this as a personal failure of young people is cruel. They are already climbing a never-ending mountain, there is no need to knock them down a few feet by claiming they could reach the top, if they hadn’t wasted pennies on luxury commodities, especially when you reached the top of the mountain by private jet. Furthermore, why aren’t young people allowed nice things? Is wanting to stream films such a crime? 

The current system is stacked against young people

In the pandemic, streaming services provided much needed escapism from constant news about death tolls and political infighting. Why should I forgo rewatching Gilmore Girls or watching the newest Netflix original, so I can pretend I might be able to buy a house in the next 10 years. 

Exercise is important for physical and mental health. I’m not going to pretend that an outdoor run isn’t free, but it also isn’t the only form of exercise available. Gym memberships allow people to use weights and machines they otherwise couldn’t afford. Most importantly, they allow access to swimming pools. The ability to swim is lifesaving and it is crucial that people have access to learn and practice this skill. These little respite moments where we don’t have to produce labour are important to avoid burnout and make life more bearable. 

The current system is stacked against young people and there is little hope from my peers that homeownership is doable, even with well-paying jobs. Allsopp’s comments were at best ignorant, and, at worst, downright hurtful. I’d dare argue that those of us with no connection to the House of Lords may just have a slightly harder time navigating the market, than those who were able to buy a house 30 years ago, or those whose parents were able to help. What do I know though? I’m not a presenter of a Channel 4 property show, I’m just a 20-year old with a Netflix subscription and a bleak outlook on the future of housing.

Illustration: Elle Fitzgerald