The reborn doll: is the backlash justified?

By Charlotte Wilson

Mothers of ‘reborn dolls’ have been recently shot into the spotlight after achieving virality on TikTok. The practice of mothering an inanimate doll as an adult may seem odd, but to some it can be an important coping mechanism for dealing with stress or fertility issues. However, recent events have made TikTok users wonder how far is too far when it comes to treating these dolls like they’re real. 

So, what is a reborn doll? Simply: they are dolls that are modified to make them more realistic looking. The term ‘reborn’ refers to this process: by reshaping or painting them to mimic a young baby’s skin, they are ‘re-borning’ the dolls. This transforming of baby dolls rose in popularity in the UK and US in the 90s and has grown through online communities. A significant number of them are seen as just a collector’s item – and it is not uncommon for them to be swapped or traded within the community, but there is a significant number of people that do use them for roleplaying, treating them like a real baby. There are several genuine benefits of this from helping people deal with grief, infertility and they can benefit the emotional wellbeing of people with dementia according to some studies. But despite the positives, what comes with this is ‘reborn mummies’ who arguably take it too far. 

At its core, there is nothing inherently wrong with buying baby formula just to pour it down the drain

The TikTok user Mummyof2reborns, real name Millie, has recently come under fire for ‘feeding’ her reborn real baby formula amidst a national shortage. At its core, there is nothing inherently wrong with buying baby formula just to pour it down the drain, or at least no more than there would be if you were doing it with Fanta for example, after all, it’s just her wasting her own money. Despite this, nineteen-year-old Millie’s comments have been flooded with criticism with one user calling her ‘disgusting’. The issue that they take is that she is using baby formula that is needed for real babies, and that because of her, people aren’t going to be able to feed their children. 

Firstly, this feels a bit dramatic. Is using up resources that are required by other people great? Obviously not, and undoubtably the more empathetic thing to do would be to allow real children to be prioritised. But it’s unlikely that one or even a few people buying formula they don’t need is going to have a huge effect on what is described as a ‘national shortage’. What is needed there is intervention and support on a much larger scale. This term: ‘national shortage’ keeps coming up in the comments, but generally more detail is not given. Research would tell you that the nationwide shortage is taking place in the United States, having begun during the COVID-19 pandemic, as companies suffered from supply issues. This deteriorated as Abbott Labs had to recall their products after five babies suffered from bacterial infections after using their formula. 

If you see content that annoys you, instead of rushing to comment hateful things, simply block the user and don’t watch the content that makes you feel that way

One of the brands that Millie used was Kendamil, a baby formula brand based in the UK, who have pledged to send two million cans of formula to the US in order to help with the shortage. If she was American and using up these sparse products, it’s fair to say this would be an issue, but she’s not. Judging from her accent, spelling of the word ‘Mummy’ and shopping hauls from shops such as John Lewis and Boots, Millie appears to be English. This means the shops from which she buys her formula are unlikely to be experiencing a shortage, and so she is not necessarily taking formula from babies that need it at all. 

It’s understandable that parents struggling to feed their children would feel upset and angry to see her videos in which she displays the formula that they’re unable to get. But it’s not Millie’s fault and it is unfair for them to misdirect the anger that they feel surrounding the issue at her. A different content creator received backlash recently for complaining that her heating was broken, resulting in her going to stay at Savoy, and it felt similarly out of touch and insensitive towards those struggling to afford to heat their house during the cost-of-living crisis. However, again, it’s not her fault that this is happening. Perhaps both of these situations offer a lesson to TikTok users: if you see content that annoys you, instead of rushing to comment hateful things, simply block the user and don’t watch the content that makes you feel that way.

Image credits: Pixabay