A slippery slope: the danger of romanticising frozen water

By Charlotte Wilson

By now, most people have heard about the tragic Solihull accident that took place on 11th December 2022. Four young boys were playing on a frozen over lake when the ice gave way and they fell in. All four of them went into cardiac arrest and were sadly unable to be saved. By all accounts, emergency services did everything they could, with one responder ending up in hospital himself after attempting to smash through the ice with his bare hands. The Area Commander of the local fire service gave a statement in which he expressed his sadness regarding the incident, before going on to branding it a “stark reminder to us all of the dangers of open water, especially during the winter months. Frozen lakes, ponds, canals and reservoirs can look picturesque, but they can be lethal”.

Unfortunately, it is looking as though this ‘reminder’ did not have the expected effect on everybody. In both London and Liverpool, onlookers were shocked to see more people playing on the ice, just days after the horrific incident took place. In Glasgow at least, the Council have been taking steps towards public safety by smashing the ice around the edges of frozen ponds. Theoretically, this is supposed to prevent people from venturing onto the surface, to skate or play, acting as both a physical barrier and a reminder as to how thin the ice may be. However instead of being appreciated, or even acknowledged as the attempt towards health and safety that it was, residents have slammed the council team as trying to ruin people’s fun on the ice. It’s an unpleasant surprise to hear of fully grown adults expressing more concern for temporary fun than human lives, but it appears to be the reality of the situation.

It’s an unpleasant surprise to hear of fully grown adults expressing more concern for temporary fun than human lives, but it appears to be the reality of the situation

So, what is the answer? It has been suggested that the romanticisation of ice skating on frozen ponds is to blame. It’s a fair claim to make – it even taking place in Disney’s Inside Out, with the protagonist skating across a frozen pond as one of her ‘core memories’. But the genre in which it is more prevalent is probably Christmas movies, where couples constantly are found romantically sweeping across the ice. It even appears in Christmas décor, with statues of people skating on ponds, bundled up in glittery Santa hats. This is a difficult vision to shift: when it comes to Christmas traditions, people are more willing to look past their problematic nature. And if you dare to condemn either a tradition or a film, you’re risking people labelled as ‘woke’ and trying to ‘cancel’ something people enjoy, and only resulting in encouraging them to continue out of spite.

What all of this really points to is a lack of education on the matter

What all of this really points to is a lack of education on the matter. If children were taught the true danger of playing on frozen lakes, ponds and rivers, they wouldn’t grow up into adults that value the fun and aesthetic of ice skating over the health risks. It has been made apparent that parents simply telling their children is not enough, and so it must come from somewhere more authoritative.

The closest comparison I could come to is the education children receive in Australia regarding bushfires. Many schools include it as part of their curriculum, teaching their students the dangers, debunking misconceptions, and educating students on how to protect themselves. Both bush fires and frozen ponds are fairly seasonal hazards, (although the seasons in which they occur are different in Northern and Southern Australia) and so it seems that if they can do it, so should we! If children are taught at a young age quite how lethal falling through ice can be, and to simply avoid it, hopefully there will never be another incident like the one at Solihull.

Image: Alberto Quaglia