The power of art on a pedestal

High art verses ‘low’ art, perfection verses the average Joe, permanence verses the transitory. These were just some of the ideas that flew about the packed Union debating chambers on Monday – the Art History Society’s first lecture. Guest speaker Annabel Howard from Art History Abroad discussed public sculpture by looking at Michelangelo’s David and comparing it to the epitome of twentieth Century art, Antony Gormley’s Fourth Plinth in Trafalgar square.

Stop someone on the street and ask them to name a piece of art and chances are, if they have been exposed to the smallest amount of culture, they will sight Michelangelo’s iconic sculpture ‘The David’. At the pinnacle of the high Renaissance (1501-04), the young Michelangelo boasted that he could see the “forms of a figure asleep in the marble” which was just waiting for his hand to wake it up. The subject, taken from the Bible, is the young king David when he faced the giant Goliath. David represents the small city of Florence surrounded by aggressors at a time when Italy’s power resided with individual cities and states. Unlike previous work on this subject, Michelangelo created deep psychological tension and put emphasis on the character of the boy rather than the success of the battle, picturing David thoughtful and pensive before he faces the giant. He deploys classical, mathematical, humanist perfection to inspire the people of Florence to strength and greatness as they passed the sculpture in the Grand Piazza daily.

What does a women standing holding an NSPCC sign have in common with the David? “Nothing”, you might say. However, Anthony Gormley disagrees and has been demonstrating this in Trafalgar square. For the first 100 days of this year the empty fourth plinth has been occupied by 2,400 real people who were picked at random from nearly 32,000 applicants. No longer is public sculpture exclusive but inclusive. It presents the everyday man and woman as heroes alongside statues of Kings, Queens and Nelson. Gormley challenges our presumptions about who can represent art, what art consists of, and how we experience it. Whether the people on the plinth are being idolised and mounted up as inspiration and celebration of what the British public is, or whether it shows the cynical loss of faith in humanity, has become a question of authorial intent. The lecture drew our attention to this and challenged the audience to question what twenty first century art is. Unlike Michelangelo, Gormley asks us to interpret and participate in the art. Whether you see the plinth as a protest or pole-dance platform; studio or stocks; playpen or pulpit; as a frame for interrogation or for meditation, it has provided an open space of possibility for many to test their sense of self and how they might communicate this to a wider world.

It led me to thinking about the role of public sculpture and wondering what an hour on the plinth would inspire me to do. For those of you who have not noticed, the equestrian sculpture from Durham’s market square has been removed leaving an empty plinth, so maybe its Durham’s turn to create living sculpture!