President Obama needs to take a firmer stance with Israel

The knowledge of President Barack Obama’s recently awarded Nobel Peace Prize lingers uncomfortably in the air as his plans to restart Israeli-Palestinian peace talks disintegrate after a series of US blunders.
On June 4th 2009 Obama made a speech to the Muslim world from Cairo and, with regards to the Middle East situation, stated that “Israelis must acknowledge that just as Israel’s right to exist cannot be denied, neither can Palestine’s” and demanded a halt to construction of Israeli settlements in the Palestinian territory of the West Bank.
Given the influence of AIPAC (the American Israeli Public Affairs Committee) in American politics over the last decade Obama’s ambitious promise took many people by surprise. The pro-Israel group’s political stance on the Middle East is controversial; its critics have denounced it as a ‘de facto agent’ for the Israeli government with anti-peace intentions.
Still, the Obama administration made their claim loud and clear; that the building of Israeli settlements in the West Bank had to stop. Hillary Clinton even went so far as to say that settlements already in existence should not be allowed to expand and those in the planning stages be scrapped. Not even the heavily disputed region of East Jerusalem, which the Israelis view as one half of the capital of the State of Israel, was given any kind of exemption.
The Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas reaction to this stance was positive. He praised a new and different American policy towards the Middle East and it seemed that there was hope for renewed peace talks between him and Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu.
Unfortunately, Israel openly refused to comply with President Obama’s demands, but instead of condemning the actions he seemed to change the US political position.
In Israel on October 31st Hilary Clinton made a speech praising Mr Netanyahu’s announcement that he was going to ‘restrain’ the building of Israeli settlements rather than ‘freeze’ them altogether. The concessions that Netanyahu made included halting the building of any new settlements and continuing on the commissioned settlements at a slower rate. This was, indeed, unprecedented, but not the total halt that Obama had implied was required.
The Middle East Peace process is a complex and delicate matter and evidently Obama’s stance has been far more balanced and Arab-friendly than his predecessor’s. The problem is that his apparent inability to Israel get to adhere to US wishes imply that he is surrendering to Israel and backing down on promises to the Palestinian government. This causes further ramifications on both the Israeli and Palestinian sides as the apparent change in Obama’s position lessens the likelihood of negotiations.
His actions have also caused problems within the Palestinian state; the Islamist group Hamas, who won Palestinian elections in 2006, are gaining popular support as the Palestinian people become yet more sceptical towards America and its foreign policy. Despite Hillary Clinton maintaining that the settlements are “illegitimate” the Arab press has reacted badly, portraying Obama as pandering to the Israelis and denouncing Abbas and his more US friendly Fatah party for placing their trust in the new American administration.
With his authority weakening daily, Abbas announced on November 5th that he would not stand for re-election in January, and the increasing support for the Hamas party is disconcerting for Obama, as they would be far less willing to involve the US in Middle Eastern affairs. Hope for reconciliation before the election is also dwindling as Abbas has made it abundantly clear that until the building of settlements in the West Bank has completely stopped there can be no hope whatsoever for peace talks. The loss of Abbas will be a huge blow to US attempts to bring peace to the Middle East. Abbas’ political views- to abide by the 1967 Israel-Palestine borders, naming the West Bank and Gaza Strip Palestinian territory with a capital in East Jerusalem- do at least entail a two-state solution.
In Israel, contrastingly, the public opinion of Netanyahu couldn’t be higher. It seems to his party and his people he has won a resounding victory over both the Palestinian’s and Barack Obama. With much of the building on West Bank settlements still continuing as before, the Israeli Prime Minister has openly defied US wishes and not suffered any repercussions.
The question remains, however, whether it was ever likely that Obama would be able to fulfil his promise to stop the building of settlements. Apparently his administration thought so, as the shine has recently been coming off the golden President and ruining his credibility and prestige by doling out false hope in the Middle East is not the best way to polish him. In order for Obama to resolve this situation, help a moderate leader remain in power in Palestine and progress towards peace he needs to take a stand against Israel and clearly lay out his political decision concerning the West Bank.