The political reaction to Prince Andrew’s tenancy arrangement
By Ben Pettit
Politics Editor’s Note: Since this article was written, Andrew Mountbatten Windsor has relinquished the title of ‘Prince’ and has moved out of Royal Lodge.
The financial and constitutional autonomy of the Royal Family is directly under parliamentary scrutiny following fresh controversy involving Prince Andrew. During Prime Minister’s Questions on the 22nd of October, Sir Ed Davey, Leader of the Liberal Democrats, demanded a select committee inquiry to “properly scrutinize” the Crown Estate’s opaque dealings. This political challenge was sparked by a report in The Times, which outlined how the prince is occupying The Royal Lodge in Windsor Great Park under highly favourable terms – most controversially, an annual rent of “one peppercorn (if demanded).” This clause, a technicality to make the contract legally binding, has ignited cross-party outrage and opened wider questions into the relationship between Westminster and the Crown.
The 30-room Royal Lodge, that is reportedly worth around £37 million, is owned by the Crown Estate, which gives all profits to the UK Treasury for the nations benefit. In 2003, Andrew signed a 75-year agreement with the Crown Estate, paying an upfront premium of £1 million with a further commitment to £7.5 million necessary for refurbishment. This, in effect, was an upfront payment to avoid any further rent obligations for 75 years, as seen in the clause which stipulates an annual rent of “one peppercorn (if demanded) – a token sum used the make the contract legally binding. Due to the nature of the lease agreement, if the prince were to be forced out of the property, the Crown Estate would have to pay him £558,000 of taxpayer-manged funds, alongside a ‘compensatory sum’ of £185,865 yearly until 2028. This development came to light at the same time as the publishing of Virginia Giuffre’s posthumous memoir, which outlined the horrors she faced at the hands of convicted child sex offender Jeffery Epstein and, as she alleged, Prince Andrew. The prince’s consistent denial of the allegations has done little to quell the public backlash to his associations with Epstein which caused him to step away from public life in 2019.
”The prince’s consistent denial of the allegations has done little to quell the public backlash to his associations with Epstein which caused him to step away from public life in 2019”
The political response from these developments has been swift and cross-party. They began with Liberal Democrat leader Sir Ed Davey during PMQs, where he called for a select committee inquiry, something Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer responded to with ambiguous support, stating that “It’s important in relation to all crown properties that there is proper scrutiny, I certainly support that.” Davey proceeded further, asking the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) chair to launch an inquiry and summon the prince to give evidence. The political momentum is not exclusively from the Lib-Dems – Stephen Flynn, Zack Polanski, and Kemi Badenoch, leaders of the SNP in Westminster, Green party and Conservatives respectively, have indicated support. The pressure on the government to act is not solely external either, frustration has built amongst ministers who believe the government should take a stronger stance, one stating “We should be throwing him under the bus. He does us no favours”. Parliament’s reaction has moved beyond just rhetoric, with the former SNP and Labour MP Rachel Maskell targeting the princes’ hereditary titles. While he did voluntarily ‘give-up’ the use of his dukedom of York, it cannot be officially revoked without an act of parliament. Stephen Flynn’s Early Day Motion (EDM) called for a debate into the legislative process of removing Andrew’s titles, while Rachel Maskell introduced a private members bill which aims to remove the prince of his titles and provide the monarch with greater power to do so in the future. These actions can be seen as reflective of the public sentiment, as YouGov reported that 4/5 of Britons agreed that the prince should be stripped of his Dukedom.
”While he did voluntairly ‘give-up’ the use of his dukedom of York, it cannot be officially revoked without an act of parliament”
Despite this growing pressure for scrutiny, the government has refused to give MPs time to debate the issue, citing a convention of not interfering in royal matters, as well as the Royal Family’s desire not “to take time from other important issues”. It is worth noting that parliamentary rules prohibit MPs to reflect or debate the actions of the Royal Family unless it is based upon a substantive motion. However, the government’s decision underscores wider constitutional tension, the deference paid to the sovereign’s authority leaves the fate of Andrew’s dukedom stuck in a constitutional grey area.
The direction of this issue will be shaped by the PACs decision regarding an inquiry, and whether the growing political pressure will force the government into conceding time for a debate, which itself risks the discussion widening into a review of the constitutional place of the monarchy. At its core, the optics of a disgraced royal retaining such privileges have issued an outcry which places great strain on the relationship between the Government and the Crown.
Image: Chatham House via Wikimedia Commons

