The centrists strike back: How the Dutch liberals may have upended populism 

By Barney Weeden

Barney Weeden unpacks a shock liberal surge in the Netherlands what this means for the European populist trend and wether a stable and popular government can be formed.

On Wednesday 29th October, the Netherlands headed to the polls for an early general election, following the collapse of what journalists have called the most right-wing cabinet in modern Dutch history.  

Fragmented vote shares deepened Dutch political volatility and delivered a surprise: the centrist-to-centre-left Democrats 66 (D66) won the most seats for the first time ever, with 26 of 150 seats in the House of Representatives. This put them level with Geert Wilders’ radical right populist Party for Freedom (PVV), whose poll ratings have nosedived in the last year. 

To understand 2025’s results, it helps to revisit the similarly startling 2023 election in which the PVV soared to first place with 37 seats giving them an unprecedented mandate for a party often deemed too radical to govern

The result echoed a continental rightward shift and was driven by frustrations with outgoing Prime Minister Mark Rutte. His part, the centre-right People’s Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD) had led coalitions since 2010 but had faced criticism over migration issues and housing shortages. 

As the Dutch proportional voting system requires coalition-building, Wilders’ 37 seats, 39 short of the 76 required for a majority, forced negotiations with three other parties; the centrist New Social Contract (NSC), the VVD, and the right-wing agrarian Farmer-Citizen Movement (BBB), which surged after the 2022 Dutch farmer protests.  

The PPV’s hardline anti-immigration policy generated worries among NSC and VVD politicians regarding rule-of-law compatibility and international obligations. After a tense 222-day negotiation period, a cabinet led by former intelligence chief Dick Schoof was finalised on July 2nd 2024.  

Heated debates on asylum policy, environmental restrictions on farmers and EU policy meant the Schoof cabinet seemed doomed from the beginning. Rifts between moderate conservatives and right-wing populists paralysed policymaking and in June 2025, the PVV exited the government over unreconcilable differences on migration policy. The government collapsed and new elections were called with the NSC exiting government in August over disputes on Israeli government sanctions.  

The 2025 campaign mirrored the chaos of the government preceding it. Rob Jetten’s D66 presented a progressive, pragmatic and pro-European alternative, becoming the face of change. His messages of stability, affordable housing, climate action and renewal resonated with younger voters and moderates. 

Meanwhile Wilders doubled down on his anti-immigration stances, maintaining his core base but alienating moderates. Dilan Yeşilgöz’s VVD struggled to reshape its post-Rutte image, and the NSC and BBB collapsed: the former squeezed by a rejuvenated D66, and the latter by PVV dominance among anti-establishment voters.  

The results were the tightest in 70 years. D66 and PVV took 26 seats each. This represented a nineteen-seat increase for D66, whilst PVV lost eleven seats

VVD took 22 seats, reducing their share by two seats, while the left-wing socialist GreenLeft-Labour (GL-PvdA) took twenty, down by five. The centre-right Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA), led by Henri Bothenbal, rose from the dead to claim 18 seats, thirteen more than in the 2023 election.   

The leading party in government from 2006 to 2010 have the most popular leader in the country according to a survey in July by Dutch broadcaster RTL. This popularity evidently translated electorally. Meanwhile, the BBB fell from seven to four seats and the NSC were wiped out completely, losing all twenty seats. The party now faces an identity crisis after the resignation and retirement of their central figure, Peter Omztigt in April 2025.  

Even though moderates now hold more of the seats in the House of Representatives, the electoral mathematics remain painful. Whether Jetten looks left or right for coalition partners, the machinations appear fiendishly complex.  

A D66-VVD-CDA coalition would have 66 seats, ten shy of a majority. Adding GL-PvdA to that would mean a decent majority (86 seats), but economic, environmental and social policy tensions between left-wing progressives, centrist liberals and centre-right conservatives would almost certainly arise.   

Frans Timmermans resignation as GL-PvdA leader may pave the way for more centrist leadership, but deep ideological divides will remain. Jetten will need to balance his pro-European progressivism with pragmatism if he seeks a stable government. 

The Netherlands will enter 2026 in much the same way it did 2024. The country must navigate questions of coalitions, a divided legislature, and public fatigue from instability. The period of political turbulence is far from over, and this election has merely begun another chapter in the Dutch democratic battle between pragmatism and populism.

Image: Public Domain Dedication via Creative Commons Zero