The pointlessness of passive politics
By Samuel Rackind
Passive politics is pointless. It is rather futile to continue denouncing the Chinese government for their activities in Xinjiang.
Ultimately, they control the region, and thus, out of all other state and non-state actors, have the most control over the flow of information in and out of it. This covers any attempt to accuse China of genocide (and many other heinous crimes) in a legitimate cloud of doubtful dust that cannot settle.
Unfortunately, in this age of misinformation, it can be very hard to establish anything as fact if so many people claim otherwise: a speck of doubt will always remain. This is exactly the defence China hides behind in international fora. That, and their ability to force political outcomes their way thanks to sheer strength.
However, by our Western standards of what constitutes valid information, the question of whether anything reprehensible is happening in Xinjiang is history: the salient question is how do we stop it.
The salient question is how do we stop it.
With that out of the way, let’s look at how this can be done. If we consider the fact that the persecution of Uighur Muslims in Xinjiang by the Chinese government is reaching (and may well have already reached) a level of severity comparable to the Holocaust, it is ridiculous – mindboggling – that our response is so bland.
While my knowledge of the Allied response to the Holocaust is limited, what is certain is that the Allies went to war with Germany, and subsequently freed Jewish people held in camps. There are, of course, many intricacies to this sweeping statement and to what really happened, but it is not an outlandish claim to make.
Should our response be to go to war with China?
Should our response be to go to war with China? In an ideal world, the short answer is yes. The long answer is that it is despicable to sit here and watch this go by. Whatever we do, it must be serious and meaningful. It cannot merely be lip service.
The tragedy taking place before our very own eyes merits such a reaction. If (probably when) this goes down in history as a genocide, then we want to be on the right side of history.
We want to be on the right side of history.
Passive responses to this tragedy, such as not buying products made by Uighur Muslims in forced labour camps, are farcical. Is this really how the West will have championed their ideals of liberty across the world and helped the vulnerable?
Let’s say that boycotting all products coming from these camps was to put the labour camps to a halt. Ok, now what? The Uighurs will not be freed. Very little will change. A more credible alternative would be that officials in Beijing will find other ways of dealing with them, which already exist and are already in practise. Forced labour camps are only a part of the story. Unfortunately, international politics is never as simple as just waging war with any state that commits atrocities, and I recognise that. There are many impracticalities associated with just pulling the trigger.
That is the rational and pragmatic side of this author. But his human side struggles to stand by while innocent people are being subjected to atrocious treatment, especially when he is Jewish.
Image: Jamiejohndavies via Creative Commons

