The other right-wing party: does Reform UK pose a threat in 2024?
By Ingrid Sykes
Reform UK outperformed predictions in recent by-elections, winning 13% of the vote share in Wellingborough and 10% in Kingswood. Their leader, Richard Tice, asserted that Reform now represents “a significant force” in our national politics, declaring these victories a “defining moment.” Labour, however, overturned these seats, meaning that more voters have ultimately defected to the left. Nonetheless, Reform’s recent electoral gains undoubtedly indicate that PM Rishi Sunak will also be challenged from the political right.
If Reform does pose a threat to both the extent of the Conservative’s forecasted defeat and the working sizeof Labour’s predicted majority, which policies would they pursue? Founded in 2020, Reform UK is essentially The Brexit Party re- named. Continuing Nigel Farage’s capitalisation of European populist trends, Reform promotes far-right social ideas. Central to their manifesto is nationalism prevent in immigration and increasing defence spending, accompanied by proposals to leave the European Convention of Human Rights. The party even includes a pledge to ban ‘transgender ideology’ and ‘critical race theory’ in schools.
Richard Tice: “The Tories have broken Britain. Labour will bankrupt Britain. Starmergeddon awaits”
Reform held a conference in Doncaster last Saturday to unveil their 2024 manifesto. Mr Tice announced an unparalleled agenda of tax cuts that aim to woo different sectors of the electorate. Plans to raise the threshold between the basic and higher rate of income tax from £50,0000 to £70,000 aims to attract middle earners as inflation has recently pushed workers like teachers and nurses into higher tax bands. A policy raising the lowest threshold for the basic rate from £12,570 to £20,000 would mean seven million would not pay income tax at all.
Reform’s message is presented as ideologically radical yet opportunistic. Reminiscent of the American MAGA movement, Reform markets itself under the slogan “Make Britain Great,” aiming to target disillusioned voters. Mr Tice recently utilised this message in The Daily Telegraph: “Our country is full of talentand energy…. yet weak leadership and failed management has led us to the edge of the precipice”. Mr Tice attacks both major parties and yields adversarial devices: “The Tories have broken Britain. Labour will bankrupt Britain. Starmergeddon awaits”.
But do these ideas and messages have an identifiable base of popular support? A YouGov survey last Thursday found that only 13% of the electorate intend to cast their ballot for Reform at the next election. Conservative officials fear Reform will split the right-wing vote in key, marginal constituencies. However, the dominance of our two-party system ensures that Reform cannot achieve a working majority. Nonetheless, both parties will incorporate their ideas and elements of their rhetoric to prevent voters susceptible to Reform’s message from defecting. As the Conservatives are ideologically closer to Reform than Labour, they have sought to push them aside by pursuing the Rwanda immigration policy whilst broadcasting the slogan “Stop the Boats” and by hinting at potential tax cuts that aim to make voters feel better off and boost popular opinion of the government’s economic management before the election.
When few participate, voters tend to be more ideologically motivated
While Reform indirectly influences politics in this regard, its potential to improve upon the Brexit Party’s breakthrough in 2019 remains uncertain. First, Reform cannot solely shout from a platform of Euroscepticism and a no-deal Brexit now that the UK has left the European Union. Replicating a similar tangible policy implementation to Brexit will remain a challenge. Low turnout in the recent by-elections means that pundits cannot reliably predict Reform’s performance in the upcoming election.
When few participate, voters tend to be more ideologically motivated. The vote share of the more fringe third parties — traditionally insignificant at the general election due to higher turnout — increases at these unexpected elections as the likelihood of the disillusioned or more generic, moderate voter showing up lessens. Voting intention polls suggest that Labour is so firmly placed to pick up disenchanted 2019 Conservative voters that if Reform were not an option, only a quarter of these voters would switch back to supporting the government.
Whether Reform is successful in the general election or not, it represents a strain of our politics that traditional parties struggle to address. Labour is on track to gain a working majority, yet Reform will not disappear after election night. Reform constitutes the most explicit representation in Britain of the populist movement that has swept through Europe since the conclusion of traditional, post-war party politics.Ultimately, as long as this age of grievance politics continues to capitalise upon blame- based political strategies, far-right populist parties like Reform UK will linger in the background of the political scene.
Image: Chiral Jon via Wikimedia Commons

