Speaker Kevin McCarthy: ousted by his own party

By Ingrid Sykes

For the first time in the history of American politics, the House of Representatives has removed their Speaker, Kevin McCarthy, by 216 votes to 210. Due to the Republicans’ small majority, eight right-wing Republican rebels were able to remove McCarthy from a job that he had only held since January, after the November midterm elections. Speaking to CNN, McCarthy declared that the U.S. “is too great for the small visions of those eight” who were not “looking to be productive.” The Republican revolt was led by Matt Gaetz, representative of Florida, in retaliation against McCarthy’s recent deal with the Democrats regarding the debt ceiling of public spending.  

Such sentiment stemmed from the rebels’ fear that McCarthy would not enact their ultra-conservative principles on the legislative floor. This was reflected when McCarthy was finally elected as Speaker with a small majority of 216 votes, after 14 rounds of voting where the House floor saw shouting, finger-pointing and even a Republican congressman being restrained.

Where does McCarthy sit on the Republican spectrum? Initially, he supported Trump’s claims of voter fraud but then reversed his comments after the 2021 storming of the Capitol. In Republican fashion, McCarthy opposed raising federal spending. However, his recent negotiation with the Democrats, which proposed to extend government spending for 45 days, was only motivated by his desire to prevent a government shutdown.

Congress cannot fulfil its crucial legislative function until a new Speaker is elected. 

But does the Speaker of the House really have an influence upon the political agenda? Unlike the Speaker of the Commons here in the U.K., the Speaker of the House is one of the most powerful positions in Washington. Ultimately, they run the lower chamber of Congress. Their powers include maintaining order in the House, permitting members to deliver speeches and announcing an impeachment inquiry into the President. Most significantly, they decide which bills are voted upon. Therefore, Congress cannot fulfil its crucial legislative function until a new Speaker is elected. 

The consequences of the ousting of McCarthy are huge. Firstly, the proceedings of Congress have been disrupted. Maryland Democrat, Jamie Raskin, declared Congress’ normal work has been ‘thrown out the window’ and has led to ‘the worst political rhetoric’ he has ever seen in Congress. The House is now on recess for the week to enable discussions for the vote of a new Speaker. However, there were upcoming matters on the House agenda which needed to be attended to, including decisions over aid to Ukraine and the annual federal budget.

Notwithstanding, the fiasco ultimately highlights the dilemma of polarisation which has been increasing within American politics since the 1990s. Democrats and Republicans are vehemently divided ideologically over the amount of federal debt the government can incur. Democrats believe spending cuts prevent meeting previously legislated financial obligations that aim to progress society, such as healthcare and social security. However, Republicans conservatively argue that the economy is damaged by increasing budget deficits. The Republican’s rebellion against McCarthy’s compromise demonstrates that when agreement cannot be found, Congress is threatened by gridlock and a government shutdown. Ultimately, such hyper-partisanship means Congress cannot carry out its constitutional legislative role.

The fiasco ultimately highlights the dilemma of polarisation which has been increasing within American politics since the 1990s

Even the Democrats who compromised with McCarthy voted against him along the partisan line. Whilst polarisation in Congress has been asymmetric (the Republicans have moved further to the right than the Democrats have moved to the left), it appears that Democrats were happy to vote along partisan lines instead of preventing the chaos that has subsequently ensued. Hakeem Jeffries, the leader of the Democratic minority in the House, has called for bipartisanship: “it is our hope that traditional Republicans will walk away from MAGA (Make America Great Again) extremism and join us in partnership for the good of the country.”

In his press conference, McCarthy announced that he would not run for Speaker again. Currently, Patrick McHenry from North Carolina is temporarily holding the post. According to the rules of the House, he is not empowered to enact votes on legislation. At the time of writing, there is no clear successor to replace McCarthy. Inevitably, keen Republican representatives will be eager to advance to such a position. Accordingly, Steve Scalise from Louisiana and Ohio’s Jim Jordan have announced their ambitions. Given the small Republican majority and the absence of bipartisanship within Congress, the election of a new Speaker will certainly be a long and convoluted process. Inevitably, opinion polls are now reporting that the confidence of the American public in their government is almost near a historical low. As polarisation is now an irremovable component of US politics, the feeling that Congress is broken abounds.  

Image: US Department of Agriculture via Flickr