The other issue with the “man’s game” quip

By Tommy Isaksson

“It’s a man’s game”. Graeme Souness’s reaction to Chelsea’s blood and thunder draw with Tottenham Hotspur sparked immediate outrage and the long-time Sky Sports stalwart was across the media headlines on Monday to defend himself. Not so long ago, such a comment would have been unquestioned and seemed both natural and true. In 2022 — rightly — this is no longer the case. The defence provided is believable, but troubling.

The fact that Souness meant nothing against women’s football with his remark — which was unfortunately worded given the claim that football is a ‘man’s game’ has long-standing sexist undertones — is believable. In answer to the reaction of many: there is nothing wrong with describing men’s football as a game played by men. It is factually accurate and, at the end of such a day of Premier League action, it would seem frankly bizarre for Souness to be itching to knock the women’s game down a notch.

What he meant, he says, was that Sunday’s games felt like a throwback to a different era of football, when the English top flight’s reputation for physicality, passion and some good old-fashioned hostility was justified. We saw established top-half West Ham beaten at a buoyant City Ground by a scrappy goal which immediately enters Nottingham Forest folklore, whilst Thomas Tuchel and Antonio Conte leapt at each other’s throats as the red mist descended over a London derby between blue and white.

This lack of a tribalistic, confrontational urge does not exclude them from football or manhood

Personally, there is nothing wrong with celebrating all of this. Tuchel and Conte’s antics reminded me more of representations of childish petulance than of manly burliness, but that is a different debate. The issue here is with this idea of what it is to be a man, and what about that you need to play football.

The context of Souness’s comments, as he has outlined, were that Sunday’s games — amid the new refereeing directives to encourage a more flowing game — were fast and furious, with physicality aplenty, tensions boiling and tempers a bit hotter than that. In short, therefore, it was a man’s game played by men getting about each other, fighting with everything they had for the points.

Here lies a problem. ‘Men’s football is a man’s game’ is a fact. ‘Men’s football is a man’s game because it was a brutal battle on and off the pitch’ assumes ideas of what it means to be a man. There will be plenty of men out there who do not see themselves ever being involved in a thirty-man ruckus over whether one bloke should look the other in the eye when he shakes his hand.

This lack of a tribalistic, confrontational urge does not exclude them from football or manhood. The context of Souness’s comments suggest that it does. If the referee blew the whistle every time any contact was made, but the game was still between 22 men, it would be a man’s game. So why only describe it as such when the tackles are flying, and chaos threatens to rule?

Men’s football is indeed a man’s game; however, that means all men regardless of their character, physical attributes or anything else

Souness’s ‘man’s game’ portrays a particular idea of manhood — and an unhelpful one at that. A game of strength and force and aggression. This is an idea which will put off scores of young men and women from accessing the joy I got from a decade of playing as a child and a lifetime of supporting my team through thick and thin (but a lot more of whichever is meant to be bad). Souness presents an idea which hints to all men what society thinks a proper man is, and the idea that football is constrained to a certain type of men is damaging for both people and the sport.

Footballing cliché tells us Manchester United’s trip to Brentford on Saturday was ‘men against boys’. Why? It was the organised, the excellent and the hungry against the spineless, the gutless and the downright rubbish; but what does any of that have to do with being a man or a boy?

Last I checked, ‘man’ or ‘boy’ is a distinction of age, not of some mental or physical characteristics. Men who play football need not be battlers, warriors and fighters. Men’s football is indeed a man’s game; however, that means all men regardless of their character, physical attributes or anything else. Souness may be right, and we may “have our game back”, but that does not make it any more or less of a man’s game than it already was.

Image: Ben Sutherland via Flickr