The original aim of higher education has been lost

By Simone Clericuzio

A university education is like love: if you have to pay for it, something must be wrong. In this sense the UK has turned into a loveless country where harlotry prevails. The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills has estimated that in 2013 alone a cohort of 314,000 new students enrolled in a university-level institution and that the Higher Education Initial Participation Rate for the academic year 2013-2014 was 47%. These figures show the willingness of people aged 17 to 30 to pay up to ÂŁ9,000 per year to get an HE degree. The reason? Getting a decent occupation and afford a lavish lifestyle. Personal growth or making the world a better place now score badly among ambitious university students.

Every year around 300,000 young people in this country are fooled to believe that a university degree is a necessary condition for them to find a job and that this is worth spending tons of money. With an ever more competitive job market, the argument goes, receiving a university education is getting to be a necessity, not just to stand out in front of a prospective employer, but merely to have the chance to be considered. This is the story of how we accepted as normal the fact that we are spending several thousand pounds to receive a kind of education that our parents were used to getting for free, when education had a less pragmatic and materialistic purpose.

Don’tt get me wrong: university studies are an enriching experience that will leave you an imprint as you would not find anywhere else. What is disheartening, though, is the amount of money that the simple act of studying now requires. Young graduates in the UK are now burdened with an unmanageable debt that will impair their life choices and prospects for the years to come. It is not just a matter of financial endowment and the opportunities this entails: paying to study, in fact, basically transforms the nature of knowledge itself, it leads to its reification. The summa of the human intellectual accomplishments has been reduced to the standards of ready-made meals: there no longer exists the pleasure to buy your own fresh ingredients, decide which ones to use and which to avoid to suit your own tastes, be tempted by new combinations of flavours or just decide what you actually want to eat. Now it is always the same tasteless and standardised food that we are forced to ingurgitate. This is the modularisation of knowledge, a standardisation of learning, inevitable with mass schooling. But why does such a state of affairs exist? What can be done to change it?

If the first question is difficult to answer, the second is useless: no one will bother to acknowledge that university intended as a service to be sold and bought is a degeneration of the Enlightenment ideal of a knowledge to be spread. This is the major problem: the idea that a university degree is good per se, and that everyone, his actual skills and interests notwithstanding, ought to pursue one. This reality has a double root. On one hand, university has become a way to postpone the moment youths enter the job market. The decreasing need of labour by Western society has led to a structural rise of un- and under-employment, making compelling the search for ways to prolong the unproductive phases of life. On the other, there exists the belief that human existence without an elite education cannot be enjoyed, both from a financial and intellectual standpoint.

While it is certainly true that university constitutes an intellectual pleasure, it is not ascertained that it is the only one. In such a state of mind whoever would feel entitled to ask for more while at university, perennially dissatisfied by the perception that his money is not getting him what he was looking for. And, needless to say, this made possible for HE institutions to charge ever more for their services, to market the message that a degree from the university so-and-so will create a positive impression in future employers, that it will lead the graduate to stand out.

The objectification of university has transformed the attitudes with which high-school students face the great leap. While not too many decades ago it was not a rarity to hear someone wishing to learn for learning’s sake, to study to change the world for the better, now it seems that the majority of graduates aim at a prestigious job in a bank and a thoughtless life. How students think about the years 17-21 is both a cause and consequence of the reification of learning.

Can all of this be changed? Yes, if we change our cognitive understanding of HE. Is it normal that college has become a fundamental step in someone’s growth process? Was Tony Blair’s desire for a student boom reasonable? No, to both questions. A containment of HE studies should be the priority. While this policy might annoy the university industry, it would be a strength for society. Youths would not be forced into an unpayable debt, a wholly state-funded HE for willing and able students would finally be made (or remade) attainable and higher studies would be tailored to individual needs and attitudes. No more modularised knowledge, standardised exams and mass-market textbooks and the such that have turned students into profit-maximising robots.

Photograph: