Arts students who question the value of their degrees are missing the point
By Tom Barber
Universities that deliver ‘excellent’ teaching will soon be able to raise their tuition fees in line with inflation in a move announced by George Osborne last year. This move will go some way to delivering the marketization of higher education that was intended when the tuition fee cap was raised in 2012. The least contentious aspect of the change is the linking of the prerogative to raise tuition fees with high quality teaching, yet this raises the seemingly unchallenged implication that universities exist primarily to teach.
If this is the case, then rising tuition fees will be particularly galling for those studying degrees in the ‘soft subjects’: the arts and humanities. Indeed, it is something of a running joke that those studying these subjects are throwing their money away in the subsidisation of more expensive degree programmes. Tuition fees make up 43.3% of total income in UK higher education institutions, with no financial discrimination between faculties at undergraduate level. Despite this, only 3% of expenditure goes on humanities, language studies, and archaeology, a mere fraction of the 19.4% of expenditure given to STEM departments (HESA). It is a crude slur to suggest that humanities students might look at such numbers with an expression of acquiescent befuddlement, but for some reason, courses in the arts and humanities are still being taken up in great numbers and with great enthusiasm, despite the disparity in teaching.
So, when students embark on the not inconsiderable investment of a university education, do they really believe that they’re just paying to be taught? Shunning any claim to be representative, I took an unscientific scroll through The Student Room and was far from surprised by what I saw there. The first answer to the succinct question ‘is uni really worth it?’ was the somewhat more sarcastic ‘is a decent salary really worth it?’. Indeed, it seems that, for many, a university degree is a sensible investment in improved career prospects and higher salaries. Whilst the spiralling cost of university and increasingly tumultuous job market render the potential return of such an investment debatable, it is not a debate in which I intend to embroil myself. What we can all, however, agree on is the fact that those with degrees in the arts and humanities get less bang for their buck than their STEM counterparts: of the top 5 highest earning degrees 10 years after graduation, the only non-STEM subject to make an appearance is law (IFS).
Despite the unavoidable realisation that those studying the humanities are investing a great deal of time and money in their university education, whilst getting very little in return, in terms of contact hours and graduate prospects, humanities students still attempt to justify their degrees to their usually exasperated parents. In a last ditch attempt to resist the tide sweeping them towards the inevitable law conversion or reluctant PGCE, they cling to that overhanging Bourdieusian crag of ‘social capital’. But, of course, one would not find oneself in such tumultuous waters if one had not missed the boat in the first place, as there is no immutable link between arts degrees and the acquisition of ‘social capital’; an individual can come by social capital simply by virtue of studying at university or simply by being in the right place at the right time, without subjecting oneself to abysmal career prospects and endless hours in the library.
So what exactly is left for those studying ‘soft subjects’ in a world where education for the sake of education is becoming less and less affordable? Humanities degrees certainly cannot be called a good investment or a project of self-betterment. Rather, those who are asking what they can expect for their tuition fees are asking a question which is motivated by self-interest, fuelled by the capitalist marketization of education, and ultimately misses the point. Indeed, I put it to you that an investment of time and money in a humanities degree is part of a thoroughly selfless social enterprise. To unashamedly perpetuate yet more crude stereotypes, those who study ‘soft subjects’ are politically active, culturally aware, and emotionally engaged; indeed, faculties of arts and humanities are involved in the creation of a highly educated general population, an endeavour which can only be applauded in a world where division fuelled by ignorance is increasingly rife.
Thus, those humanities students who question what they stand to gain from their degrees seem, to me, to be failing to grasp exactly what those degrees should be teaching them: the importance of cultural awareness and social responsibility in combating the rising tide of general ignorance. No answers to this problem might be sought in the ivory towers of the natural sciences, or the darkest dungeons of computer technology, but only in the creation of a highly and broadly educated population. To ask, then, if the study of the arts and humanities is ‘worth it’, is in fact to ignore the social impetus which is at the heart of such a course of study.
Image: Wikipedia via Creative Commons
