The Man from Earth review: ‘failed to impress’

By Liam Gill

Jerome Bixby’s The Man from Earth is an intellectually stimulating piece, exploring deep philosophical concepts, which challenge our most basic presumptions of religion, relationships, mortality, and science.  As a contender for one of my personal favorite films, it was with great anticipation that I trekked to Collingwood to see Collingwood College’s presentation of the stage adaptation of the film.

While the play did successfully convey the basic principles and messages of the original script, a combination of flawed directing and large production oversights prevented the play from truly succeeding in challenging the audience to contemplate the deep issues being discussed.  While a large part of the issues can be credited to the venue, the Collingwood Dining Hall not being the ideal setting for a production, it was unfortunate that the Director (Andrew Entwistle) and Production team (Catherine Jones, Jess Green, Lucy Burnett) where not able to properly create what is a relatively simple naturalistic set of a living room with only a sofa.  The problems with the set caused a domino effect, as issues in regards to blocking, a visible backstage area, and an awkward outdoors area (which may have been confusing to anyone who hasn’t seen the film) truly burdened the production.  Further issues regarding makeup for older characters, which looked awkward, and actors moving on frozen blacked-out sets also held back the performance.

Most criticism should be born by Entwistle, who failed to properly adapt the script to the cast and set he chose.  Consistent mentions of the fireplace or comments by Edith (Yasim Jones) about being chilly, felt misplaced without a fireplace being included in the set.  Additionally the casting of Shari Bone as Dan should have warranted a large reworking of the character. Throughout the play Bone was referred to by the male name of the character and it was confusing to others and myself whether she was meant to be portraying the original male character or a female adaptation, as her actions and mannerisms appeared awkward and slightly manly. As an integral foil to John Oldman, the character of Dan needed to be more convincing and better directed. As a whole, all the supporting characters appeared to be caricatures of the characters in the film, with the roles being played so comically that it distracted from the story being conveyed. Had Entwistle been willing to take risks in creating his own version of the piece instead of a copy of the film, I believe that with the cast at his disposal, this could have been a far better production.

The acting itself is difficult to judge as its unclear what the Director required of the actors. A general comment being that it was extremely confusing whether the actors intended to use American accents, as apart from Harry (Jason Hong) none of the characters seemed to attempt an accent. However references to their being in the US were plentiful, sticking to the original script. First night jitters could explain struggles with lines by Bone and Jones.

I was particularly impressed with the standout performance of Louis Mayo, as John Oldman, playing the character to near perfection, he was a great joy to watch and truly kept the audience engaged in his story about being a caveman who had lived for over 14 millenia. Ellie Shearwood was also impressive in her role as Sandy, helping to advance the plot and story without interfering in the flow of the play, as other secondary characters consistently did. Josh Cavendish also deserves a mention for his convincing and entertaining portrayal of Dr.Will Gruber.

Overall while the play as a whole failed to impress, an incredible script, coupled with a tremendous lead in Louis Mayo, managed to convey the deep philosophical ideas to the audience, making this a worthwhile watch. Had their been a more distinct creative vision and better direction, Collingwood College could truly have had a show-stealing performance. While the film may be preferable to the trek to Collingwood, I would recommend that students near the venue check out this production, which is intellectually gripping and entertaining despite its flaws.

Photograph: Raffaella Lobb and Samuel KirkmanÂ