The History Boys review: ‘room to grow’
By Sofya Grebenkina
Entering the North Road Methodist Church I can confess that I was somewhat discouraged at the prospect of watching an all-female production of Alan Bennet’s The History Boys. Yet Prohibition Theatre’s offering did little to sustain this prejudice that I had attained through watching the very successful film adaptation of the play. Instead what happened was as desired; the artistic merit of the casts overtook any concerns I could have had about their gender.
Gender concerns relegated to the side-lines, this cast managed to bring out the themes which were central to the play, age, sexuality and the fight between art, culture, and education. At the centre of it all are an unconventional class of boys, who for what seems to be the first time in the school’s history, have a real chance of achieving a much-coveted place at Oxbridge. With the help of their new teacher and supposedly a graduate of Jesus College, Irwin, the boys are set to a path marked for success, which both their Headmaster and they themselves begin to believe in.
This three hour-long production was a definite triumph for some of the cast. In particular, Poppy Kelham as Hector, in both her mannerisms and clear affection for that subject of ‘General Studies’, whose definition escapes all, was palpable throughout her entire performance. Charlie Whitehead, as Irwin, made a chilling contrast to Hector. The young man’s cold demeanour and passionless affinity for that boundary between cold hard fact and results made Whitehead a noticeable presence whenever on stage. It became clear why Dakin had such a desire to please.
Francesca Sollohub, as Totty, however was uninspiring with her uncertain movements completely contrary to the nature of her character. And throughout a large part of the beginning of the play she was also completely unintelligible, due to the low volume of her voice, so that many lines carrying a large amount of humour were entirely missed. As the only female character in the script it was a shame to see such an interpretation. Clementine Vann-Alexander, as Headmaster, was also somewhat of a let down. Although Vann-Alexander’s posture and facial expression were consistent, the success of her characterization did not extend beyond that. Each line seemed to have the same cadence and so its sense was occasionally not carried in the manner of her speech.
The cast were certainly bolstered by the excellent script, however it was Abbie Cole, as Dakin, who managed to make the character entirely her own. The confident posing and Cole’s searching gaze, as if yearning for everyone’s approval, made her an attractive character. She was also one who utilized the space of the stage best, in contrast to someone like Louisa Quarterman, playing Posner, who mostly stood rigid and motionless whenever she was on stage. However her soprano voice suited her character perfectly and the brief intermissions of song heard between some of the scenes were performed with great care and beauty.
The setting of the church gave the sense that the words of the play were somehow to be afforded reverence. Even though Rudge may describe history as, ‘one fucking thing after another’, it was to be understood that the events that this play documented were worthy of them being put into writing. The set itself was sparse yet just enough so that our attention was solely on the actors. The makeshift wall which ran along the back of the stage was plastered with images of famous and influential women, a lovely touch, and a reminder of the all-female cast of the play. However it did not go all the way across, which made it appear jarring and somewhat distracting.
The costumes however deserve the highest commendation. Each boy had their uniform mirror their particularities, and Irwin, who was often remarked on by others to be like a schoolboy wore something semblant of their uniform. Yet although Hector’s suit was true to his age, there were no attempts made to age him, so that Kelham would occasionally appear clownish or absurd, drowning in tweed and wearing round glasses, without meaning to do so.
The History Boys has been a good first start to Prohibition Theatre’s repertoire. However there is much room left to grow, if not conceptually, then in terms of individual discrepancies in acting and some mistakes made with set. Overall none of the play’s nuance or significance had been lost, and that is perhaps their greatest achievement.
Photograph: Grace Tseng
