The lost perspective on the crisis in Ukraine
By Michel Krysiak
A Palatinate article published on 15th February reads: “The difference for Western analysts of the crisis in Ukraine right now is that they do not have the luxury of declassified Russian sources from within the heart of the Kremlin to assess the nature of Putin’s intentions.” Well, it does not take declassified Russian sources to know that Russia is currently occupying Crimea and Donbas, contrary to the author’s sentiment that “Russia has not invaded Ukraine.”
There is a common misconception in Western media that the matter of discussion is a potential threat to Ukraine. Many writers and even ‘analysts’ completely disregard the fact that the current crisis is an escalation of the Russo-Ukrainian war, which dates back to February of 2014. To give you an idea of the scale of the conflict, the overall number of confirmed deaths in the Donbas war is 13,000 people. The day I began to write this article (Thursday 17th February), shelling broke out in the area, with a kindergarten as one of the targets. Today (22th February) the Russian troops are already in the area of so-called ‘Republics’, the separation of which was staged by Putin’s proxy forces.
A superficial understanding of the region and its past is not enough
I am not here to point out the author’s ignorance or to answer the question posed in the article, but to point out how it is a very good example of how the Western press tackles the current crisis. The piece that “examines the parallels between the Cold War and a potential Russian invasion of Ukraine” shows that Western commentators desperately strive for a historical comparison in order to place the conflict in a context that is easier to comprehend. However, at the end of the day, a superficial understanding of the region and its past is not enough to draw any strong conclusions.
I do not wish to target the Palatinate piece as a singular example wrongly assessing the current situation in Ukraine. After all, a similar outlook has been presented by both western journalists and politicians alike. Reviewing the recent press, you can notice that liberals from the West ask if they should support Ukraine in light of the neo-nazi problem it is facing. Articles discussing the far-right violence in Ukraine and calling its citizens ‘fascist’ have emerged as an argument against the West’s interference. One can’t but wonder why these pieces avoid comparing the extent of the issue in Ukraine to that in Germany and Belgium, where the far-right have a stronger representation, even in the countries’ parliaments.
The crisis has also attracted several self-proclaimed experts of the east of Ukraine, discussing the national identity of the inhabitants of those territories. A map published by The Washington Post went viral on Twitter, which shows the percentage of the population that identified the Russian language as their native language, with a number of commentators retweeting it as evidence of the rightfulness of Russia’s claim to these lands.
The map was not only misleading, but its very concept is useless in this context as well. Being Russian-speaking hardly means being pro-Russian in a country where people had been pressured to abandon their language by a body of laws and decrees that date back to Tsarist and Soviet Russia. As some Twitter users pointed out, that linguistic frame is comparable to arguing that Ireland should be re-invaded by England because the majority of its citizens claim English as their first language.
Support among Ukrainians for membership in NATO has been on the rise
As I have mentioned before, politicians’ reactions revealed similar skepticism towards supporting Ukraine (and a similar level of understanding of the conflict). Just a couple of days ago Young Labour accused Keir Starmer of siding with ‘NATO aggression’. Now, I am not here to discuss the rights and wrongs of NATO. I am here, however, to point out that Ukraine has been a partner of NATO since 2020. The popular support among Ukrainians for membership in NATO has been on the rise since May 2014, consequently revealing that the citizens wish for such involvement. That hardly indicates that the organisation’s engagement is an act of aggression. However, Russia’s opinion on that seems to be in more regard to the ‘progressive’ side of Western Europe (for example Jeremy Corbyn, who blames NATO for ‘provoking’ Russia).
The current commitment to the wary reactions to Putin’s moves is a far cry from initial sentiments displayed by, for example, Joe Biden, who on 19th January proclaimed that Russia “will prevail over time” if they invade. Still, even now, it is more likely that you will see USA President’s quotes on Ukraine as headlines rather than those of, for example, Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
It is safe to say that for now the Western press along with the politicians has been assuming two positions: one that seeks ‘objectivity’ and as a result succumbs to the Russian outlook on the war, and one that discusses how the potential outcomes of it would affect their own people.
Between those two perspectives, one is lost: the Eastern European one.
While Western leaders were discussing how to appease Putin and show him the ‘respect’ that he demands, and the journalists worry about the US “risking embarrassing itself and its intelligence if Russia chooses an option other than invasion”, Eastern European states have been preparing for the worst scenario, as their media pointedly note which foreign diplomats left Kyiv. In Poland, cities declare how many refugees from Ukraine they would be able to accommodate. Lithuania’s central bank warns the country’s banks to make proper preparations in case of Russian cyberattacks.
These preparations are completely overlooked by the Western media, even though they are indicative of how seriously the conflict is taken within the former Eastern Bloc. Citizens of the countries that have a long history of the struggle against Russia do not have delusions about its ambitions, which have been imperialistic in nature for centuries now. Leaders remember Georgia in 2008 and know that Putin will not hesitate to send troops where and when the opportunity arises, both in Eastern Europe and Central Asia. The imperialistic tone of Putin’s speech came to them as no surprise.
The language of diplomacy covered up that of commerce
As I have noted before, Ukrainian voices are similarly disregarded. Despite the open calls for support, such as a request for defensive weapons, leaders and the general public of the West alike hide behind the empty claims of pacifism and worry about Ukraine’s autonomy. But between Germany arms export hitting records while not only refusing to support Ukraine, but also blocking Estonia from doing so, and the polls showing that the American youth is against the government involvement in the war while the White House seizes Afghan assets worth $7bn, one must ask what the actual concern of the West is.
Ultimately, the reason why the Eastern European frame of reference is so overlooked, remains the same: business.
The argument against supporting Ukraine is hardly rooted in the sudden care about Eastern European nations’ autonomy, but rather in the fact that the West has more money to lose in the conflict than it can gain. It took the German Chancellor weeks and hearing Putin openly admitting that he believes that Ukraine is not a ‘real’ nation for the German Chancellor Olaf Scholz to halt the certification of Nord Stream 2. It took the Russian troops to be deployed into Donetsk and Luhansk for Boris Johnson to launch the first sanctions. And between the speech and the Russian soldiers already on the Ukrainian territory, Jeremy Corbyn still is not convinced as to what exactly the motives of Putin are.
At the end of the day, President Zelenskyy’s worry that the West would impose sanctions only after a possible invasion, and not before, has been proven to be true. It took so long for the Western leaders to mobilise because, as the language of diplomacy covered up that of commerce, Eastern European voices became drowned out.
What this says about the West’s commitment to the self-proclaimed “European values”, I will leave for the reader to judge.
Image: Max Kukuridizak via Unsplash

