Crisis in Ukraine: start of the next Cold War?
By Rosie Knighton
As Russian troops amass on the borders of Ukraine amidst frantic Western attempts at diplomatic negotiations, Defence Secretary Ben Wallace has said that ‘it may be that [Putin] just switches off his tanks and we all go home but there is a whiff of Munich in the air from some in the West.’ The situation is reaching breaking point, with the UK Foreign Office having told all British Nationals last week to leave Ukraine whilst they still can. Certainly, there is a ‘whiff of Munich in the air’, but taking a more long-term comparison, could this be the start of the next Cold War?
Since the fall of the Berlin Wall, a great deal of source material has been declassified allowing historians to reinterpret the history of the Cold War. In popular memory, the fear attributed to the War is very real. For example, recently collecting oral histories, the BBC has shown just how much effect the war had on people’s everyday lives – one man said that it still haunts him to this day: ‘I can still remember watching the president on TV and being so scared that I had cold chills’.
In popular memory, the fear attributed to the Cold War is very real
More than perhaps any other moment of the period, the ‘Thirteen Days’ of the Cuban missile crisis were conceived as when the Cold War was most likely to turn ‘hot’. Following the declassifying of sources, exchanges between the characters of Kennedy and Khruschev suggest that for their part, ‘hot’, and in the case of the Cuba crisis, war, was never the desired outcome.
Writing to Kennedy on 27th October, Khruschev stated that ‘these issues have so far not been resolved, but they are awaiting urgent solution’. In response the following day, Kennedy replied that ‘The United States government will be prepared to discuss these questions urgently, and in a constructive spirit’.
Such sources have led analysts such as Ray Cline to in fact see the chances of war in this supposed period of ‘maximum danger’ as as small as one in a thousand. However, what Cline neglects to recognise is the depth of the situation in Cuba. For example, the same day that Kennedy wrote this letter to Khruschev, a US U-2 spy plane was shot down by the orders of the general in command at the time, Lieutenant General Stepan Greko. Whilst the agendas of Khruschev and Kennedy at this point may not have been to pursue a ‘hot’ war, the nature of the chain of command meant that things could happen, both quickly and irreversibly.
Why, then, is this relevant to the situation in Ukraine? Well, first and foremost it is important to note that as yet, Russia have not invaded Ukraine. As Wallace said, this could all blow over, and as some argue, Putin does not want to invade Ukraine, he is simply trying to mount pressure on the West and NATO.
Will the tenuous nature of the situation lead to an accidental outcome first?
However, with an estimated 100,000 Russian troops currently deployed next to Ukraine’s borders and a further 30,000 running military exercises in Belarus, one cannot help but hark back to the revision of Cline’s argument about Cuba. Even if Putin decides not to invade Ukraine, the situation is at breaking point – one bullet accidentally fired over the border in an ‘exercise’ could very much lead to a ‘hot’ war.
The difference for Western analysts of the crisis in Ukraine right now is that they do not have the luxury of declassified Russian sources from within the heart of the Kremlin to assess the nature of Putin’s intentions. With the US and UK firmly standing by the policy that they will not take direct military action in Ukraine, the circumstances compared to Cuba are certainly different in that respect.
The press suggests that the next few days will show whether the outcome of the crisis will stem from diplomacy, as in Cuba in 1962, or military attack and the consequent sanctions from the West. The question no one is talking about is whether the tenuous nature of the situation will lead to an accidental outcome first. Whatever the outcome, one cannot ignore the parallels with the Cold War.
Image: Official White House Photo by David Lienemann

