The Lessons of History

By James Meakin

On the 5th March, just before Coronavirus hit the United Kingdom with a vengeance, Professor Pieter Judson from the European University Institute in Florence visited Durham to deliver a lecture on the lessons we can learn from the Austro-Hungarian Empire today. I briefly want to outline what he thinks those lessons are before. I will subsequently argue that European politicians are failing to heed the lessons of Habsburg history.

After the fall of the Empire, the history of the Austria-Hungary was dominated by nationalist intellectuals such as Hungarian politician Oszkar Jaszi. Jaszi’s magnum opus was his 1929 work The Dissolution of the Habsburg Monarchy. He argued that the “ethnographical mosaic” of the Habsburg Empire meant its dissolution was inevitable from the beginning. Judson strongly pushes back against Jaszi’s long-term view in his 2016 book The Habsburg Empire: A New History. He argues that the 1914-16 Junta of General Conrad von Hötzendorf destroyed the Empire since it pushed for too much centralisation and unleashed unseen violence against ethnic Ukrainians and Serbs.

Judson’s main ‘lesson’ from the Habsburg Empire today is that supra-national government works since it can be an antidote to ‘populist nationalism.’ He cites the example of the Polish nobility who, despite having many grievances against the Habsburgs for annexing parts of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth in the 1770s, were still happy to serve in senior governmental positions in Vienna. The Habsburg Empire was a success, until 1914, because it was able to integrate nationalists into government.

Supra-national government, when enacted in the right way, is an antidote to populist nationalism

After having studied the Habsburg Empire and read a sizable proportion of Judson’s book, I believe many European politicians should too. They should consider the case of Hungary. Most Emperors in Vienna recognised that Hungary was a special case. It was quite clear that there were many sore points in the relationship between Vienna and Budapest though. In 1849, the nine leaders of the 1848 Hungarian Revolution were executed. Then, in 1867, a Schrodinger’s compromise was negotiated between Vienna and Budapest. Hungary would have its own government but there was also an Austro-Hungarian government. Far from being a “prisoner of peoples,” the Habsburgs were wise to keep its various ethnic groups on a loose leash.

The lesson with the 1867 compromise for the European Union is this. The EU, like the Habsburg Empire, is supra-national, multi-lingual and plagued with many internal and external problems. Despite this litany of problems, the EU is not doomed to fail. However, the EU will create further distractions if it is not willing to negotiate reasonably with its member states and neighbourhood. Case in point – the United Kingdom.

There was a time when the United Kingdom still wanted to be part of the EU but be treated as a special case or leave but have a close relationship. This approach was scorned as “cherrypicking” or “cakeism” by Donald Tusk, Angela Merkel and others. A looser EU would be more efficient since it would spend less time negotiating with nations worried about further centralisation and more time tackling more pressing issues such as migration and climate change.

Alas, support for a looser federation can now only be found in the Dutch government. The United Kingdom was repeatedly rebuffed, humiliated and is walking away to a more distant relationship with the EU. In the form of Ursula von der Leyen and Charles Michel, it seems like the Hötzendorfs of Brussels are taking over.

As the words from a musical set in Austria go – “so long, farewell, auf wiedersehen, goodbye!” The EU is clearly failing to learn the lessons of a previous European supra-national state.

Image: Nathan Hughes Hamilton via Flickr