The horse meat scandal is food for thought
Among Tesco’s heart-felt apologies and an astronomic quantity of wasted food, the horse meat scandal seems to have had two positive effects. The first is the abundance of horse meat-inspired memes, puns and videos that has flooded the internet – because there’s nothing like a clip of someone dressed as a horse trotting around Tesco neighing “where’s my mum” to put a light-hearted spin on the whole fiasco. The second is that, with any luck, it will prompt us to think twice about what we pick up from supermarket shelves, and about what we put into our mouths.
The traces of horse meat found in tens of thousands of products around Europe clearly labelled ‘beef’ has quite rightly provoked uproar. It’s easy to dismiss the commotion as a result of that very British habit of being squeamish towards the idea of eating any animal that children give names to, or even, as a far-fetched article in the Guardian suggested, our attachment to the idea of the horse as a chivalric war-hero. But this goes far beyond British particularities; indeed the scandal’s all over the French front pages too, and we know they love a good horse steak. Whilst some may chose not to eat horse meat for whatever reason, the unavoidable and unacceptable issue here is that every customer who bought a horse-tainted beef product was essentially lied to.
Whether the problem arose from illegality or negligence, one falsely labelled product opens the door to a breakdown of consumer trust in British supermarkets. If we buy something that says it’s a cow and it turns out to be a horse then what’s to say that something saying it’s from Britain is not in fact from China? Or that something that says it’s organic is not actually packed full of antibiotics?
Robert Kenner’s award-winning film ‘Food, Inc.’ makes an important point: consumers, as a group, have a whole lot more power than we think. Each time we buy something we are casting a vote. So in paying the extra pennies for free range eggs we’re voting for a certain style of agriculture. This is all very well until suddenly there’s a doubt to whether they were ever free range at all. Any element of power disappears and we are forced to be ignorant buyers fuelling a system that we have no control over. This might seem to be blowing the issue hugely out of proportion, but there’s no avoiding the fact that today’s food industry is wound up with far greater issues; issues that effect the livelihoods of the vast numbers of people who work within it, the environment we all live in and our own health.
The horse meat scandal has brought matters into the open: the difficulty in tracing the complex journey made from horse to plate is alone enough to illustrate just how commercialised and profit-driven our food industry has become. In the current economic climate consumers demand low prices and manufacturers go to every length to meet demands – the fact that the price of horse meat is around half of that of beef is no coincidence.
As students, many of us eating on a budget, these problems become particularly pertinent. It’s all too easy to assume that one cheap product we buy couldn’t possibly make a difference, especially if it means you can put ten burgers on the barbecue instead of two. Obviously there’s a certain amount of truth to this, but there will always be the argument that a widespread change in mentality has to start somewhere. Ethical buying is not a privilege reserved for the wealthy, and if the demand for ultra cheap food lessens perhaps people and the environment can afford to be put back into the equation.
The horse meat scandal stands to show the decline in the attention paid to food production. Having had this reality exposed to us we are now in the position to make certain choices. Of course, boycotting Tesco and Iceland when you live in somewhere like Durham is easier said than done, but in buying local products from independent companies whenever possible the chances of untraceable, undefinable ingredients are reduced. Maybe by handing over our money to organisations whose policies we agree with we can avoid the possibility of ending up with another suspiciously horsey-tasting beef lasagne.

